Protected tree at the root of property dilemma

A couple who spent $400,000 restoring a category one historic inner-city home have found themselves left with part of the property landlocked by a lack of access.

The couple say they are blocked by a covenant and Dunedin City Council rules from developing or selling the land.

Eve and John Jackson restored the Basil Hooper-designed Ritchie House in Heriot Row, before selling it to St Hilda's Collegiate School last year.

Now, they want to fell a protected tree on what was part of the garden, a subdivided section they say St Hilda's did not want.

Removing the tree would create a building area for a prospective buyer where it did not affect surrounding houses.

Despite a ''long-standing attachment'' to the site, they have attracted opposition from neighbours and other opponents who made submissions at a resource consent hearing yesterday.

''Catch 22, it's called,'' Mrs Jackson said.

The scheduled maple tree is more than 80 - and perhaps 100 - years old.

It is listed as significant on the council's schedule of trees, which means it cannot be removed without resource consent.

Recent public notification of the consent application attracted 11 submissions, 10 of them opposing the tree's removal.

Council staff have also recommended the hearings committee considering the application reject it, because the tree is healthy and a prominent feature of the area.

The committee hearing the issue was chairman Crs David Benson-Pope, Lee Vandervis and Aaron Hawkins.

Mrs Jackson told them the couple's ''small family business'', Drysdale Ltd, bought 26 and 28A Heriot Row in 2003.

Both were in a ''very rundown condition''.

The house was restored inside and out, and sold to St Hilda's in 2013.

The committee heard the school was the only buyer found for the $1.5 million home, but it did not want 28A.

The couple planned to auction the property, but neighbours told them they had taken steps to register the garage on the property as a historic place, and the auction was cancelled.

A covenant meant any building on the rear boundary could be no higher then 3m, and heritage precinct rules required buildings to have pitched roofs.

For those reasons, the couple wanted to allow building at the front of the property, but the tree was in the way.

Mrs Jackson said the couple did not want to build, but to sell the land and realise its market value.

They had been forced into a situation where they had to pay gardening bills and rates for an empty property valued at $250,000.

At the hearing, council planner Sophie Lord said she maintained her view the consent should be declined.

In a submission, Peter Robb said the maple was rare at the time it was planted, and while he understood the Jacksons' problem, he wanted the tree to be saved.

Dunedin heritage advocate Ann Barsby said in her submission the work of Basil Hooper was ''a national treasure''.

''The garden gives the space for the house to be seen in its full glory,'' she said.

Mrs Jackson said she supported ''completely'' Mrs Barsby's right to oppose the consent. But the couple did not want to bear the cost of owning the garden ''for the enjoyment of others at our expense''.

Cr Benson-Pope said the committee would visit the site and get information on the tree's lifespan before its decision.

 

The value of a section

The section 28A Heriot Road has a protected tree and a protected garage on it and there is no access and it is impossible to build on it because of height/design restrictions, yet it is valued at a quarter of a million dollars.  Does anyone know what  one might expect to pay for a section of comparable area in a comparable neighbourhood, with access, and which can be built on?

Park it

So they made what, $ 600,000-$700,000 from their endeavours? Why not just donate the land left for a community park?

National treasure

They bought the house knowing there was a convenant on the garden section, a rare protected tree and no road access. Now they want to change the rules so they can sell the garden as a building site.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
K'N'S Marketing - Coffee DistributorsAlexandraWholesalers & Distributors
Sonny Chin and Helpers Master Body TechnicianDunedinMassage Therapists
Punavai O Le Atamai Pre SchoolDunedinChildcare & Kindergartens
Bell Hill DentalDunedinDentists