Dismay as club hears of sale plans

Caledonian Bowling Club board members (from left) Murray Tennant, Graeme Bennett, Jan Tucker, Mike Fitzgerald and Glenys Mead show their dissatisfaction with the Dunedin City Council's decision to sell the club's land. Photo by Gregor Richardson.
Caledonian Bowling Club board members (from left) Murray Tennant, Graeme Bennett, Jan Tucker, Mike Fitzgerald and Glenys Mead show their dissatisfaction with the Dunedin City Council's decision to sell the club's land. Photo by Gregor Richardson.

It has stood for 135 years - of late a haven within a hub of retail activity - but yesterday the Caledonian Bowling Club learnt its fate.

The Dunedin City Council announced it would sell the land on which the club stands on Andersons Bay Rd.

More than 50 members were told at the club last night.

They had not gathered to hear the news, it was just a normal Friday night for the club, chairwoman Jan Tucker said.

Members seethed and fired off their thoughts.

One member offered an ''alternative proposal'' to the council: ''We want this place to carry on - bugger them [the council].''

Another member questioned how the council could sell the club grounds which had been used by ratepayers since 1879.

''I can't answer that,'' Mrs Tucker said.

Another member said the news ''hurt badly''.

But council chief executive Dr Sue Bidrose earlier said: ''It's not good commercial sense for us to own land that we're not getting a return on, or that's got no strategic benefit for the council, or that's underused.''

The council said of 270 members, 32 bowled and others mainly used the venue socially and for activities such as pool and darts.

Dr Bidrose said the club had been told for several years this would be the last lease on the facility. The lease expires on October 31.

''They don't have enough bowlers to sustain their presence on a $1.5 million piece of land, and that was a problem, and they have been unable to increase their bowling club membership in that time.''

The proposed sale went through a submission process earlier this year, with 14 of 18 submissions opposed to the plan. The club is sited on council land, zoned industrial, which was sold by the Caledonian Society of Otago to the council in 1943.

Mrs Tucker said yesterday the club's board had fought to prevent the sale.

''These are the cards we were dealt and we played them bloody hard,'' she said.

''I'm pretty disappointed, sad and a little bit angry about it, actually.''

Dr Bidrose said the council had offers to buy the land.

Asked what that involved, she said: ''Just that we have been approached about purchasing the land. It's a sought-after industrial corridor, so we will sell the land.

''What goes on it depends on what somebody buys it for.''

The incoming district plan had ''views of continuing the large-scale development on Andersons Bay Rd'', she said.

The money would go towards repaying council debt.

There would be ''continuing rationalisation of properties''.

''You'll see other bits of land being sold to pay down debt. That brings down debt-related costs for ratepayers.''

Dr Bidrose said the sale of the nearby Caledonian Gymnasium had been discussed in the past, but ''at this point in time'' there were no plans to sell it.

Asked about the 137 years of history going by the wayside, Dr Bidrose said: ''We're selling the facility. The club is independent of the facility.''

She said there were half a dozen bowling clubs in a 2km to 3km radius ''all of whom are struggling with numbers, who would be happy to have some more, and, I suspect, would be happy to have 30 bowlers who wanted to maintain their own independent club structure within the facilities''.

Mrs Tucker implored members to think about the club's future.

''I realise people are angry but what you need to do now is go away and have a wee think about how we can proceed.''


New club rooms

Perhaps they could take up rugby and shift their clubrooms to Awetea St, since that's what the council intends to spend the proceeds on.

Bowling club sale

Do not sell it even if it's worth 1.5 million. It's the social cost the dcc are not taking into consideration, just leave it as it is - it's not hurting anyone. If anything council should stop wasting rate payer money on stupid projects. Yes pay down debt but sort the problems in your infrastructure basics keep the streets clean in the cbd not the present state it is in now.

Only the beginning

This is the start of many sell offs, it is sad for those involved but this Council is utterly broke. Now watch as they sell off anything they can to pay for the stadium and the $650 in consolidated debt. Mr Davies the Stadium CEO gets paid $250,000pa and he just lost over $100,000 of rate payer money underwriting a soccer game so they need all the money they can get.


Maybe they could apply For a Histotic Places Classification.

It's only going to get worse...

...but hey, at least we've got a stadium, right? 

Shame on you DCC

OK, I don't play bowls but this is another sad day for all of us as DCC residents and ratepayers. We must not let this closure happen and get behind the good folks who use this as a place for social gathering and activity. The people who want to close this are telling us they make no money from the land. Well DCC, the 'profit' you seek comes not in the finacial form but in the happiness of those who use the club, the maintenence of a degree of fitness and wellbeing they maintain, the socialising of a community and the long term use and history of the club. This might not make commercial sense but then for me a battle over some land and traffic lights costing hundreds of thousands in ratepayer money makes even less! So wake up and keep this club open and stop making those who you are supposed to be representing long for the day we can vote the councilors and the Mayor out.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Fishbone Bar & GrillQueenstownRestaurants
Razors EdgeOamaruHairdressers
Thomas Hotel Queenstown QueenstownBackpackers