Heritage restricts wish to demolish

The Chalmers Community Board is calling for the Moller Park Memorial Arch in Ravensbourne to be demolished. Photo by Peter McIntosh.
The Chalmers Community Board is calling for the Moller Park Memorial Arch in Ravensbourne to be demolished. Photo by Peter McIntosh.
The Chalmers Community Board is calling for an almost 80-year-old Ravensbourne memorial to be demolished, but has struck opposition from Heritage New Zealand.

Ravensbourne's Moller Park Memorial Arch was built in the mid-1930s to recognise the achievements of West Harbour mayor, councillor and Otago Harbour Board member Hagbarth Ernest Moller.

Community board chairman Trevor Johnson said the arch's position at the entrance to the park was ''an accident waiting to happen'' as it created a blind spot for drivers as they exited on to State Highway 88.

For this reason, the fact it was deteriorating and a lack of community attachment to the arch, he felt it should be demolished.

''It's been neglected over the years, the board doesn't believe it's worth spending money on it and we are hoping to have it demolished and relocate the plaque to a more suitable place within Moller Park.''

Trevor Johnson
Trevor Johnson
However, the community board's wish to have the arch demolished has hit a snag, with Heritage New Zealand Otago and Southland area manager Jonathan Howard calling on the Dunedin City Council to save it.

In an email to a council staff member, tabled at this week's community board meeting, Mr Howard said demolition should only be a ''last resort''.

The arch showed community recognition for an important member in the West Harbour community, he said.

The council and community should look at alternative options, such as relocating the archway or raising the exit ramp to widen the Port Chalmers side.

Council parks manager Lisa Wheeler said it was up to the council to make a decision on demolition. If a decision was made not to demolish the archway, ''there is probably going to have to be some remedial work done on it,'' Ms Wheeler said.

Earlier this year, the council planned to repair the memorial, but decided not to, after the community board said it should be demolished.

There has been at least one accident in which a driver was injured when their car crashed into the monument.

vaughan.elder@odt.co.nz

Moller Park Arch

What two gentlemen? Mr. Hagbarth Ernest Moller, Harbour mayor, councillor and Otago Harbour Board member is only one person.

Moller Park Arch

Thank you, I have no idea how to clean & check it, but there are a lot of people who do not want it demolished.
I want to know why the Board has let it deteriorate.

What the?

Owainjmorris, with due respect, waterblasting is not the process to sympathetically clean and conserve Ravensbourne's Moller Park Memorial Arch - or any other well designed monument like this. Dunedin City Council should strongly heed the advice of Heritage New Zealand on this one.

Moller Park

Waterblast it to clean it up and to see what damage there is, and leave it there. It is a part of Ravensbourne's history!

Ugly

It's very ugly- how about demolish & put up a little plaque for these two gentlemen.

 

Not much of a memory

Hmm not exactly honouring the contributions of Mr Moller with a run-down, bizarrely-located concrete arch which is creating a hazard. What would Mr Moller have wanted? Things don't need to be preserved for the sake of it.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Palmerston Health CentrePalmerstonMedical Centres
Milton KindergartenMiltonChildcare & Kindergartens
Laser ElectricalOamaruElectricians
McCormick Carrying LimitedDunedinTransport & Haulage