Policies damaging, Joyce says

Steven Joyce
Steven Joyce
Labour's policies would be damaging for Dunedin's economy and its plan to revive Hillside Workshops shows it is out of date, Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce says.

In contrast, Rail and Maritime Transport Union (RMTU) hailed the plan to revive Hillside as bringing hope to former workers yet to find skilled work since losing their jobs in 2012.

Dunedin list MP and former chief executive of Dunedin's Mercy Hospital Michael Woodhouse, was also scathing of Labour's promise to fast-track the Dunedin Hospital rebuild, calling it ''irresponsible''.

Mr Joyce said the claim National had neglected the city, made by Labour leader David Cunliffe yesterday, was false and, in fact, its ''policy mix'' had resulted in 23,000 extra jobs for the Otago region in the last five years.

That equated to an average of 4600 jobs a year, which was more than the 3000 Mr Cunliffe had promised for its entire term.

''On the one hand, I understand Mr Cunliffe's lack of ambition. A Labour-Greens government with at least four big extra taxes and large amounts of extra spending and the high interest rates that go with it would be a massive drag on the Otago economy,'' Mr Joyce said.

Reviving Hillside was ''unrealistic'' and the ''world has moved on from those days'' when it was at full strength.

''The Hillside Workshops were from another period and actually, time has changed. Investment has grown in other areas.''

Companies in other sectors, such as ADInstruments and Language Perfect, were growing ''their businesses flat out'', he said.

''I think ... Mr Cunliffe is once again just trying to say things that people want to hear and I understand that, given where he is in the polls.''

RMTU South Island organiser John Kerr, who was in Dunedin for yesterday's announcement, said it was ''completely behind'' the plan to revive Hillside.

The news would be especially welcome for workers who had found only low-skilled work since losing their jobs in 2012.

''I think they will be delighted by this. It will have given them something very precious and that's hope,'' he said.

Despite the fact some of the about 90 workers who lost their jobs in 2012 had left Dunedin, he believed there was a still a good enough ''skills base'' to work for revived Hillside.

''We are optimistic that this can work.''

He disagreed with National's claim reviving Hillside was backwards looking.

''I think that all that has happened in the free market under National is that workers and ordinary New Zealanders have become worse off.''

Mr Woodhouse said the claim the Government had neglected Dunedin Hospital was ''complete nonsense'', as during its two terms it had upgraded the emergency department, intensive care unit and psychiatric ward and ''completely rebuilt'' the children's ward.

''If there was any neglect it was by the [last] Labour government, who, in the best of times, never did a thing for Dunedin Hospital to fix up some fundamental issues.''

National had committed to Dunedin Hospital being the ''top of the list for an upgrade'' and, unlike Labour, it was waiting until it had the proper information before releasing a time-frame.

''I've run hospitals. I know how hard it is to master-plan for a new facility and I don't believe it's appropriate for anyone ... to make bold but irresponsible claims about timing.''

''We wouldn't be so arrogant to put such a time-frame on it until we had better information.''


Hotel amd the RMA

The council doesn't dictate RMA legislation and the hotel failed at this level alone. Proper due diligence and Betterways would have known the project proposed stood no chance. Some effort at compromise on location, height or design and they would have had a chance, but their attidude from start to finish of take it or leave it ensured it was a failure even before the council had their say. The council has to take responsibilty for any number of things but this isn't one of them - this project wouldn't have got off the ground in Queenstown either for the same reasons. Utilising a low profile design on any of the alternative sights they would have got a green light all the way, but I suspect higher prices for habourside apartments was what they were really after as there was more apartment floorspace then hotel. 

Central or local?

@Girraferaffle: The difference between Dunedin, South Otago, and North Otago is the local Govt. Dunedin's local Govt has created a negative business environment by turning away the hotel etc while Waitaki District Council has loaned $10m to the irrigation companies which created jobs and Clutha District Council has the amazing Mayor Cadogan who got almost all unemployed youth into work. Central Govt can help Dunedin until it's blue in the face but if DCC continues to stymie development then employment and quality of life will never go ahead.

ED's need to be attached to main hospitals

ED's need to be attached to main hospitals for the support of all the departments and staff that must be called in for diagnostic management and emergency treatments, not mention the transfer to each specialty for aftercare.


Yes, let's have a look at the figures for Dunedin

With you on that one, Girafferaffle. More to the point, the hospital needs to be rebuilt elsewhere as the current location offers no parking. I would suggest relocating the whole operation to Wakari with the exception of a small emergency department in the city.

Otago is not Dunedin

One problem we have in Dunedin is the constant reference to "Otago" when quoting statistics. Looking at Otago with respect to economic growth and jobs brings into account any gains made through the Dairy sector in N. Otago and S. Otago as well as any gains made in the QLDC area. I think I am safe in saying that Queenstown's economy is not really comparable to Dunedin's.

Let's have a look (Mr. Woodhouse) at the figures for Dunedin, not Otago. Things are looking pretty bad in Dunedin I would suggest.


Dunedin Hospital

"the former chief executive of Dunedin's Mercy Hospital Michael Woodhouse MP".

This MP of all people should have ensured that Dunedin Hospital was upgraded. The staff are working in such run down, outmoded conditions. I know one surgeon who left to go to a smaller town because it had better conditions than Dunedin Hospital.

Dunedin Hospital

Well overdue for an upgrade.

So where's National's plan?

So Mr Woodhouse, what is National's plan for Dunedin's economy? At least Labour has a plan, National's just seems to consist of hiding empty store fronts with election signs.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Hampden TavernYour TownTaverns
Buff Health & Beauty ClinicAlexandraBeauty
Design Arc LimitedDunedinArchitects & Architectural Designers
The Gate CafeBalcluthaCafés