The headline above the front page photograph and report
published in The New Zealand Herald yesterday read: "I came,
I saw, I chundered".
National television reports showed scenes of disorder and
mayhem.
Throughout the day, appalled listeners joined outraged
talkback radio hosts in discussing a variety of despicable
behaviour.
This newspaper's website was inundated with readers from
throughout New Zealand who wanted details on only one story:
that of a toga parade which turned ugly.
And an overseas tourist asked one of our staff: "Why do you
live in a city like this?"Who can blame her for asking the
question? But this isn't - or shouldn't be - Dunedin.
If anyone still doubted that the actions of a few could
reflect badly on a city, and an institution, the reaction to
events which marred Tuesday's Otago University Students
Association toga parade along Dunedin's George St should be
telling.
Once again, the city and its university made headlines for
all the wrong reasons.
The only things associated with Dunedin yesterday by people
living outside the city were drunkeness, student misbehaviour
and disgust. It is little wonder.
After all, it is beyond most people's comprehension that
anyone could actually plan to throw buckets of vomit and
faeces at participants in the parade.
But first-hand witnesses are adamant it happened - and how
else can you explain it other than premeditation? How else
could such material be collected for that use? It is beyond
abhorrent.
Eggs, bottles and rubbish were also thrown.
Shop-fronts and car windows were smashed, signs were pulled
down, some students had cuts to their feet, arms and faces.
All in the city's main street.
Of course, it is easy to stand accused of overplaying such
incidents. Yes, it is unfair to lump the blame entirely on
"the students".
Other people may well be involved. And only a small
percentage of tertiary students in the city are involved in
such skirmishes.
Students, as we editorialised this week, should be welcomed
into Dunedin.
They add life to the city, their pranks can add humour, and
education is the city's most important "industry".
However, few would deny the debacle of Tuesday evening went
well beyond mere skylarking.
While those participating in the parade cannot shoulder all
the blame - there is no doubt they were pelted with all
manner of missiles and unmentionables - one would wonder at
the levels of sobriety of many of the marchers, and
photographs published yesterday certainly showed that they
were not all innocents.
At least one participant has blamed second, third and
fourth-year students for the disorder. If that is the case,
suitable action should ensue.
The University of Otago said yesterday it would send a clear
message to those responsible that such behaviour was totally
unacceptable, but it was too early to say what form that
"message" would take.
If we may be so bold, might we suggest the message be a blunt
one: "Pack your bags."
- By the Editor
Expel or seriously reprimand worst students
I agree with Whisper. University authorities should review all the video footage they can find (even offering rewards for footage) and expel students whose behaviour was unacceptible. Alternatively, record the names of students who almost crossed the line and give them one last warning. Expelling the worst of Otago University's thugs may result in a few lost student fees, but allowing their kind of thuggishness to continue will do more harm ot the city and university in the long-term.
The privilege of education
An education is a privilege, not a given. Even when you pay for it. You are welcomed into a community to build your life skills towards a career. If you choose to jeopardise your chances of obtaining that education, then by all means apply for a job in the street crew that had to clean up your mess. Do not expect a hero's welcome into that crew, because you will have joined the real world, populated by real people, who have a real opinion about your behaviour. The truth is you will have found your true calling in life. May you spend the rest of your lives with your arms up the sewers of your host community pondering what might have been if not for a childish action not tolerated nor forgiven.
Dunedin Toga Party
Do you, dear ODT editor, really believe that the Otago University will send packing some of its paying clients?
In the eyes of the world
At a time when tourism dollars are at a premium and tourists have more choice than ever of destination, the student guests of Dunedin have yet again tarnished the city's image overseas...
The story of the toga parade ran on the BBC in the UK and the article with video was on the main BBC website news front page all day today...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/7911289.stm
Nice one guys!
Send them home
I believe that it is really important that the University does its best to identify the worst offenders and then send them home. If they get away with it, their antics become part of the Scarfie culture and the University ends up attracting more students of the same ilk (ie thinly disguised hooligans who think that binge drinking and antisocial behaviours are amusing and worthy of admiration).
Toga parade
I cannot believe police have decided not to take action. If these were ordinary citizens the riot squad would have been called out and numerous arrests made.
Damn straight
This is not the sort of behaviuor we want, this is not the sort of behavior we expect from adults. If you want to behave like this don't come to Dunedin, you are not welcome.