In the end it was Kim Dotcom's money and his "history of
taking an unorthodox route'' that saw the multimillionaire
remain behind bars yesterday instead of going home to his
family and his $30 million mansion.
The man at the centre of what has been described as the
largest copyright case in the US to date walked back into the
cells last night after his latest bid for bail was declined
at the High Court in Auckland. He will remain in custody at
least until an extradition hearing is held unless a fresh
appeal is launched.
Justice Raynor Asher upheld last month's decision by a judge
in the North Shore District Court to decline bail for the
German multimillionaire.
He said Judge David McNaughton had noted "the extraordinary
features'' of Dotcom's life.
They included "his great wealth, taking on an unorthodox
route, his connection to Germany and his incentive to get
there''.
Justice Asher said that because Germany did not have an
extradition treaty with the United States, Dotcom would be
free from prosecution if he chose to escape to his birth
country.
"He may or may not have the means to bring about such a
scenario, however it was open to the judge and constituted a
significant risk which could not be mitigated by [bail]
conditions,'' Justice Asher said.
The FBI is seeking to extradite Dotcom and three of his
associates to the US to face charges of conspiring to commit
racketeering, conspiring to commit money laundering,
copyright infringement, and aiding and abetting copyright
infringement.
The FBI-led investigation has so far frozen $23 million in a
Hong Kong bank account, $10m in New Zealand Government bonds,
$6m in expensive cars.
The Megaupload co-founder showed signs of a sore back as he
sat through the nine-hour court hearing and had to have his
seat changed.
Dotcom, also known as Kim Schmitz, addressed the court for
the first time since being arrested last month and said he
had every intention of fighting the charges so that he could
get back the millions of dollars frozen by the FBI.
"I'm aware that if I go to Germany I would be unable to
unfreeze my assets. What I want to do is stay here to fight
and get my money back. What would I do in Germany with five
kids and a wife with no money?
"It is not an option for me.''
Crown prosecutor Anne Toohey, acting for the US Government,
said there could be more money. She also said the court had
to take into account the issue of flight risk, given Dotcom
was found to have travel documents and credit cards in
different names.
She said New Zealand had porous boarders and Dotcom had
access to a helicopter.
Dotcom's lawyer Paul Davison QC said his client had changed
his name for legitimate reasons and had no intention of
deceiving officials.
He said that explained the passports and credit cards in
different names.
"You left with a business man reeling from the fact that his
business has been brought to a halt, his assets have been
seized, his family is effectively devastated by this event.''
Earlier, Dotcom told the court how, while on remand, he had
received letters from female prisoners and even a phone call
from a man claiming to be a "prosecutor" and asking for money
in exchange for a favourable bail appeal.
Dotcom said he reported the phone call to prison authorities.
Fresh from visiting Dotcom in the cells after Justice Asher's
decision this evening, Mr Davison told media outside court
his client was disappointed with the decision.
Mr Davision described suggestions that Dotcom could flee the
country by boat or jet as a "flight of fancy''.
He said Dotcom would now take advice on his next steps which
could include a further appeal or a fresh application if his
circumstances change.
Extradition papers against Dotcom are expected to be filed
later this month.
*
Dotcom and his millions:
$30 million rented mansion in Coatesville
$10 million invested in NZ government bonds frozen
Over $100 million assets frozen worldwide
$42 million earned in 2010 year alone, according to the FBI
$6 million worth of luxury cars removed from the property
Dotcom case at a glance:
January 18: District Court issues arrest warrant for Dotcom
and three others
January 20: Police raid Dotcom's Coatesville mansion. Dotcom
and three associates arrested
January 23: Dotcom applies for bail at the North Shore
District Court
January 25: Judge McNaughton declines bail at the North Shore
District Court
February 03: Dotcom's bail appeal at the High Court in
Auckland declined by Justice Asher
A name, residential address, and (preferably residential) telephone number is required from readers who comment on ODT Online. These details will not be visible to site visitors.