Police 'broke law, breached human rights'

Photo NZ Herald/files
Photo NZ Herald/files
Police broke the law and breached the human rights of hundreds of people when they blocked off a Christchurch street for seven hours to check about 200 vehicles that had gathered for a charity event, the police watchdog says.

Officers closed Maces Road in suburban Bromley on February 18, 2012 to check the vehicles that had congregated in the area, a report released today by the Independent Police Conduct Authority said.

Authority chairman Judge Sir David Carruthers said while they accepted police needed to act to control the situation given their concern about the large number of people gathered and possible disorder, their detention of people, in some cases for more than six hours, and their treatment of them during this time, was unlawful and a breach of human rights.

The vehicles had gathered about 7pm for an event described by those attending as a charity 'cruise' to gain donations for the Christchurch earthquake appeal, the IPCA report said.

Police became aware of the possibility of the event, and arrived at the street to find a large number of vehicles congregating with more than 200 people present.

They also saw some cars doing burn-outs and some disorder, the report said.

"Concerned that there was public disorder as well as a danger to members of the public, a decision was made to temporarily close Maces Road to control the scene and check the vehicles."

Drivers and passengers were instructed by loud hailer to get into their car and stay inside otherwise they would be arrested.

After the vehicles were lined up, NZTA staff inspected the vehicles while police checked driver details, the report said.

The process took about seven hours to complete, and the road remained closed until about 2am.

The authority received 31 complaints from people who were at the scene that evening.

Common issues from those complaints included being detained and the length of time people were detained; the lack of access to toilet facilities, food and water; police videoing people without consent and police being dressed in riot gear and their attitude during the operation.

"The authority has found that given the significant number of vehicles and people present, observed burn-outs and risk of injury to the public from vehicles being driven dangerously, the initial decision by police to temporarily close Maces Road was reasonable and logical," Sir David said.

"However, Police had no power to instruct drivers and passengers to get into their cars and warn them they would be arrested if they got out. This action was unlawful.

"The authority also found that the manner of treatment by police to those unlawfully detained by depriving them access to basic necessities was disrespectful and degrading. It did not comply with police's obligation to treat people with humanity and respect and accordingly breached their human rights."

Police should also not have video recorded the drivers and passengers, Sir David said.

The authority said police had already made some changes to practice and policy following this incident.

However, policy in relation to photographing people is very general in nature and restricted to road blocks.

"Accordingly, the authority recommends that police review their policy in relation to photographing or recording people and provide more detailed guidance to police staff on this issue," Sir David said.

Acting District Commander, Superintendent Andy McGregor, said the IPCA report made it clear that police had to balance varying expectations from different sections of the community when dealing with these types of incidents.

"On one hand the community expects police to uphold the law and prevent public disorder, while on the other hand car enthusiasts have the right to hold their events," he said.

"It is apparent that the number of cars encountered at the location was much higher than anticipated, and despite the best of intentions officers were unable to check the vehicles and drivers for compliance within a reasonable time frame.

"As a result of this incident, a thorough review of policies and procedures has occurred. I am confident that similar issues would not arise in any such operation today."

Police accepted the findings of the report, Mr McGregor said.

He said several unsafe vehicles were written off the road, one vehicle was impounded and one driver failed an evidential breath test, due to the checks conducted during the operation.

Since this incident, Canterbury police had run several operations targeting anti-social road users under the new procedures, without any repeat of the same concerns, he said.

Stupid Jesuitical law

The police had to break the law to 'uphold the law'?

Throw the first stone

Yes pizzazz, it happens:  " I can remember one such congregation of 'boy-racers' in Christchurch whereby a young teenage girl was hit and killed by a vehicle."  
And I can remember events and adventures organised by people for whom no denigrating name such as "boy racer" is used, people of high regard, where a mistake or a moment's carelessness resulted in a death.  
That is no reason for unreasonably stopping people without even giving them access to toilets and food for many hours, on the off-chance that something bad may happen.  After the quakes all sorts of unlikely people came forth as groups and individuals to make a difference for the worst affected.  "Boy racers" are not all lowlifes, jobless, lacking skills and compassion and motivation, not by a long chalk.  They are guys and some girls who love their cars and love showing them off.
Unfortunately some also love doing burnouts and being pests, but that's no reason to assume that as a group they would not be willing and able to organise an orderly fundraiser that combined their car passion with an opportunity to help quake victims.  Why, pizzazz, do you make the same error as the police and assume they wouldn't?

Police conduct

What a load of nonsense. A charity event? I would like to see evidence of that and how much money was actually donated to Christchurch.  I can remember one such congregation of 'boy-racers' in Christchurch whereby a young teenage girl was hit and killed by a vehicle, and there are many accounts of people getting injured around drivers acting in a reckless manner doing burnouts etc. 

The police had every right to expect there could be trouble with such a large number of people congregating, and it was probably due to the police presence that there were no injuries or worse that night. 

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Central South Island HelicoptersOamaruHelicopter & Aeroplane Flights
Peter Sara ACC Specialist LawyerDunedinLawyers
The Pet DoctorAlexandraVeterinarians
Harrex Downing & Little 2005 LtdDunedinAuto Electrical