The Prime Minister's office is standing by its tally of the
number of jobs created by The Hobbit after criticism it had
plucked the number "out of thin air".
The claim followed the release of correspondence between
Prime Minister John Key's office and Hobbit director Sir
Peter Jackson's Wingnut Films, which was obtained by New
Zealand First under the Official Information Act.
The correspondence shows a senior advisor from Mr Key's
office wrote to Wingnut, requesting a figure for the number
of people working on the film.
The advisor said that would allow Mr Key to respond to
Labour's industrial relations policy with a claim like:
"About 3000 people will work on the Hobbit movies, if that
policy hadn't been in place then all those people might never
have got jobs."
The advisor said an estimate "to the nearest 500 or 1000
would be fine".
A Wingnut staff member replied that 3000 jobs was "a good
The staff member said there were 1000 people on payroll at
the studio, 1000 at Weta Digital and almost 1000 across Park
Road Post, Weta Workshop and related companies and casual
The staff member noted "flow-on" effects while 700 people
working on the film went on the road for nine weeks, boosting
small-town economies in the likes of Matamata, Te Kuiti,
Piopio, Ohakune and Twizel.
NZ First leader Winston Peters said the documents showed
nobody had any idea how many jobs had been created by the
Government's $67 million subsidy to Warner Brothers.
"The Government claims that filming The Hobbit in New Zealand
created an extra 3000 jobs and this was value for money to
taxpayers, but documents from John Key's office show this
figure was plucked out of thin air.
"Questions have to be answered about how many of these jobs
existed prior to filming, how many of them will exist once
the final film has premiered, and how many of these jobs
actually went to New Zealanders."
He said Warner Brothers should repay the subsidy it had
received from the Government now the film had grossed more
than $1 billion.
The correspondence does not say 3000 jobs had been created -
only that 3000 people was "a good number" for those working
on the films.
But a spokeswoman for the Prime Minister's office stood by
the figure, saying 3000 jobs had been created.
"These are people who were directly working on the Hobbit. If
the Hobbit had relocated offshore these jobs would not
The spokeswoman said 3000 jobs was "a minimum" and did not
count flow-on jobs created for businesses and communities
that supplied and serviced The Hobbit.
"The Hobbit production team took 6750 domestic flights, paid
for 93,000 bed nights, and hired 1800 rental cars and 1650
"The production spent more than $9m on construction materials
and $1.5m on local food suppliers."
The spokeswoman cited Statistics NZ figures which showed the
local film industry employed 15,500 people in more than
23,000 jobs in the year ending March 2011.
"The Government stands by its commitment to attract and
retain the film industry in New Zealand in order to reap
these significant economic benefits."