While a Dunedin welfare support agency has congratulated
Labour leader David Cunliffe on his ''Best Start'' education
policy, an education specialist says it is ''not a game-changer
at this point''.
Mr Cunliffe yesterday announced details of the party's Best
Start package which would focus on the first five years of a
child's life and help families struggling to meet the rising
costs of living.
The policy aims to give children born after April 1, 2016,
''the best start towards a happy, healthy and successful life
- particularly the estimated 50,000 children under 3 who are
living in poverty''.
It will give 59,000 families with newborns a $60-a-week
payment through to their baby's first birthday.
Mr Cunliffe said the payments were in line with similar
schemes in other OECD countries, and would be available to
families earning less than $150,000 a year.
The investment would continue for parents on modest and
middle incomes until their child turned 3.
''Sixty dollars will make a real difference to the lives of
''For example, it will pay for a weekly supply of nappies and
Mr Cunliffe said there would also be free antenatal classes
for all first-time mothers and early home visits.
The package includes expansion of free early childhood
education for 3, 4 and 5-year-olds from 20 to 25 hours a
week, and paid parental leave will be extended from 14 to 26
weeks as set out in Sue Moroney's Private Member's Bill.
Anglican Family Care Centre director Nicola Taylor said the
policy was ''a very positive step in the right direction'',
recognising the significance of the early years of a child's
life in a society where there was now pressure for two
incomes to sustain a household.
''This boost of support will make a huge difference for the
first year of life.
''We deliver the Family Start programme - an early
intervention designed to support high-needs families around
the time of pregnancy, birth of a child, up to 5 years old,
''We see every day the pressures of poverty on children who
are unable to reach their full potential because their basic
material needs are not adequately met.''
Mrs Taylor also welcomed the child-care increase. University
of Otago College of Education senior lecturer Darrell Latham
said while the policy was positive, his overall feeling was
that it was not a game-changer at this point.
''There is a clear and admirable focus on ensuring that
struggling New Zealand family needs are better met and this
''However, I do have a concern in that while there is a
credible focus in ensuring that the package clearly aims to
help families struggling to meet the rising cost of living,
that granting a universal entitlement of $60 a week for
people earning up to $150,000 per year is perhaps not
targeting the resource to those who really could make the
best use of it.''
Dr Latham said the package would certainly engender support
from families struggling to meet the rising cost of living,
and the promise to increase free early childhood education
would secure the popular vote among young parents.
He said it appeared Labour was holding further policy back,
when Mr Cunliffe said the package was the first step in its
overall programme of reform.
''One thing is for certain, education and social initiatives
are going to be major platforms for this election.''
New Zealand Educational Institute president Judith Nowotarski
said research showed quality support for children and their
families in the early years, was the best ''pay back'' of any
education and social investment.
Economic Development Minister Steven Joyce said the policy
showed Labour had not learnt from its last term in
''We haven't even got to the end of January, and Labour and
the Greens are already promising to spend the thick end of an
extra three-quarters of a billion dollars a year.
''Labour's last big spending splurges between 2005 and 2008
increased the deficit, dramatically increased interest costs,
and put the economy into premature recession.
''And today they are back again singing from the same song
Mr Joyce said Mr Cunliffe needed to tell New Zealanders where
the money was coming from.
• Up to $60 for children under the age of 3.
• 25 hours of free early childhood education, up from 20.
• 26 weeks of paid parental leave, up from 14.
• More support for expectant parents.