Milk company has hosted other National high-flyers

Judith Collins. Photo / APN
Judith Collins. Photo / APN
A string of National Party high-flyers have been entertained by the milk exporter at the centre of a conflict of interest row involving Justice Minister Judith Collins and her husband, a director of the company.

Labour has promised more questions in Parliament today on Mrs Collins' visit to the offices of milk-and-scampi company Oravida in China, made during a taxpayer-funded visit as part of her justice portfolio.

Mrs Collins has staunchly stood by her view there was no conflict and she stopped to "have a cup of tea on the way to the airport". It was revealed yesterday the trip followed an invitation from Oravida chairman Stone Shi two weeks earlier.

Mr Shi asked Mrs Collins two days after a reception at the company headquarters which saw Mr Shi mixing with Cabinet ministers, party president Peter Goodfellow and current and former National MPs.

The links between the company and party are laid out on the company website and date back to March 2011, when the Trade Minister spoke at an Oravida-sponsored lunch.

Then, in August 2011, Mr Goodfellow and Auckland Central MP Nikki Kaye attended a function to celebrate the company's purchase of its waterside headquarters.

Electoral Commission records show donations worth $56,600 paid to the National Party three months later and continuing to the present.

Mrs Collins' husband, David Wong-Tung, became a director in October 2012, the same month Mr Shi played golf with Prime Minister John Key.

Oravida said the men "enjoyed the event so much that they pledged to meet again on the golf course in early 2013 in Queenstown".

A spokeswoman for Mr Key said yesterday that the planned rematch never took place but the Prime Minister had played "on a couple of other occasions in National Party 'golf days', where Mr Shi has been one of a large number of people playing".

Trade Minister Tim Groser and former Deputy Prime Minister Sir Don McKinnon, also chairman of the business-oriented NZ China Council, attended a promotional milk-drinking in Shanghai in April.

But it was the October 7, 2013, opening of the Auckland offices which saw the largest turnout of past and present National politicians.

Dame Jenny Shipley and Sir Don, both of whom have business links to China, attended, as did Mr Goodfellow. Also there was Mrs Collins, who cut the ribbon opening the office, and Police Minister Anne Tolley.

Melissa Lee, Paul Goldsmith and National-turned-Act politicians John Banks and Don Brash also attended.

Mrs Tolley said she was attending to show support for the export sector. Mr Goodfellow, a director and large shareholder in Oravida supplier Sanford, said the appearance of a large number of National people was "unco-ordinated". "I don't know who Oravida invite to their functions."

He said China was a prominent market into which NZ firms, such as Oravida, sought to export. The market had been created by the free trade agreement struck by Labour.

"What National has done is to attempt to use that free trade agreement to really drive jobs creation and exports and imports from China."

Labour's Grant Robertson said there was an "extensive network of connections between the National Party and Oravida".

He said Mrs Collins' trip was a clear breach of rules which said there should not be the appearance of a conflict of interest.

"Judith Collins needs to apologise and John Key needs to ensure his ministers don't act like this."

Otago university political scientist Dr Bryce Edwards said the Government was "highly pragmatic" and "whatever works is what's important".

"Judith Collins in her dealings with this milk company has been epitomising that," he said.

Mr Wong-Tung said: "I don't want to talk about Oravida."

- David Fisher, NZ Herald


The question still remains.  How many other milk powder export companies did Judith Collins visit or assist in the same way?

why do we have cabinet rules?

You would think this cabinet minister would have known better. Photos promoting a private company in this way would always have been contentious for any minister.

The opposition is quite rightly doing its job as excepted behavior for such meetings is clearly set out in the cabinet manual.

John Key now refuses to release the finding on the matter, why? 

Not a good look for National, a higher standard it would appear is required of cabnet ministers than national is propared to give.

The minister concerned after being questioned on the matter simply appears very arrogant.

Maybe it would have been better for the minister just admit to her mistake.

Business in China.

Great to see New Zealand Government politicians supporting by visiting our trading partners and businesses in China.

What would Labour and Grant Robertson do if he/they ever get to be in Government? Snub them perhaps?

Bigger picture

So National has an existing relationship with Oravida. This should have been reported initially because it makes Collins' visit appear like a continuation of a relationship rather than anything dodgy and new.

ODT/directory - Local Businesses

CompanyLocationBusiness Type
Puss N PoochDunedinPets & Pet Accessories
Easy Mind Homebased Child CareDunedinChildcare & Kindergartens
A + Business SolutionsCromwellConsultants
Wanaka PhysiotherapyWanakaPhysiotherapists