Undie 500 chaos - a student's view

First year student and ODT Online reporter Emily Menkes was in the thick of another unfortunate night on Castle St.

The attempts to rehabilitate the Undie 500 failed.

As with previous years, Castle Street once again experienced chaos, which eventually resulted in the street being cordoned off just after midnight, after the presence of the fire brigade and the riot police.

Earlier in the night, there was reason to believe that this year's Undie 500 would be more of a half-hearted attempt as a result of the new regulations imposed on the event. Very few cars were even in Dunedin by 10pm and even fewer were making themselves known to the locals.

Less than an hour later, Castle Street was covered with rebellious students, many of whom were making every attempt to defy the police.

The student peer pressure became apparent after a sudden surge towards the middle section of the street, with a pile of rubbish placed at the centre. A chant started, urging someone to step up and set it on fire. Several minutes passed before a student took initiative.

Three more fires followed the first in short succession, each to the apparent delight for much of the crowd. A few attempted to strengthen the fire by throwing objects ranging from boxes and plastic bags to glass bottles.

No one seemed to notice the irony of the fires' location - nearly all of them were in front of a flat that sported the logo of Beehive matches.

The emergency services soon took matters into their own hands, with the fire brigade putting out the flames, ambulance staff tending those who had been hit with glass bottles or fallen on shards.

The police eventually managed to break up the crowds around the fires, with some leaving more reluctantly than others.

One girl was seen calling her mother and lamenting, "I might be getting kicked out of university."

With the police's effective strategy of containing the area, meaning no-one could come in but everyone could come out, the party eventually dwindled, leaving behind a street of disgrace.

 

 

Read Socrates ..

I believe it was Socrates that lamented the delinquency of youth. Thankfully it is a passing phase, wisdom comes with enlightenment, and there is nothing like a finals exam to enlighten youth. Here is an enlightening thought, the poor turn out represented perhaps less than 10% of the student population. Journalism is a fraught vocation, it is easy to let the task foment the seeds of chaos with a slip of the finger on keyboard. We had a media beat up to precede the great event, and hour by hour television updates... Booze is a factor, correct. However until the community cast the moonshiners out, there will be no sense in all of this. The lead has to come from the addict to overcome the addiction, it is up to the addict's friends to help them to see with clarity the pathway to a better life.

ODT reporting

Just a question? Did the ODT pay the 'first year student' reporter more for every subjective, inflammatory statement in the article? Or does the ODT just have a quota for these types of statements that much be reached before any student related article can be published? Just wondering...

A bit of a rant in response to the Undie 500...

As a first year student, I just want to thank everyone involved with the riots for further destroying the reputation of the University of Otago. First the toga parade calamity, now this, especially the chaos reported from last night (Saturday Sept 12). I cannot understand the yearning to take part in riots for no reason other than to copy what students in previous years have done, and to gain some attention. Can they not see how their actions will affect them in the future, when they graduate and attempt to find a well-paying job? And it's not only them who will be affected in years time: non-participating students, students who actually work hard and achieve with high academic excellence, will be so as well, simply because of the senseless actions of their peers. I see nothing wrong with going out and having fun with friends, I just find it absurd that people have to push the boundaries to extreme measures to find such fun. Look at yourselves, see what effect your actions are having on your city, your university, your peers and your futures.

and..?

Did I suggest that I believed the definition of irony to be limited to "simple contradiction"? What is inconsistent, undermined, or given a very different significance here? I think a more appropriate term might be "mildy amusing juxtaposition."

@savage_lucy ironic?

Because beekeepers use fire and smoke to drive away bees from their hive. So a fire in front of a house called beehive could mean that somebody wants to get rid of the students living in there.

Irony

"A...perception of inconsistency, [usually but not always humorous], in which an apparently straightforward statement or event is undermined by its context so as to give it a very different significance." Source: writing2.richmond.edu/jessid/eng216/216terms.html The concept of irony runs far deeper than simple contradiction. You could have also tried 'googling' it yourself, I guess.

I think you'll find the

I think you'll find the article was titled "- a student's view", meaning exactly that.

Ironic?

Please explain how this is 'ironic'?

Shame on us

As a young adult, I must sadly agree with Emily Menkes's report. These rioters are giving their universities a bad name. It's a shame that we as a generation cannot exercise restraint while having fun. Back in the 1980s, the Undie 500 was not about getting drunk and behaving badly. It was about people able to showcase their creativity and ingenuity. It's a shame that we cannot have that without all the booze and trouble. The only solution would be to discontinue it if this alcoholism and disorder becomes a feature of future Undie 500 events.

Undie 500 reporting

I am totally in favour of seeing the end of the undie 500, but by golly, you gotta love the ODT's blantant disregard of objective reporting. I guess if your target demographic love hearing about the naughty "rebellious students ... making every attempt to defy police" who left behind "a street of disgrace", well, go ahead and print it.