Buses refuse to carry woman's wheelchair

A disabled woman is upset she could not take public transport between Clyde and Dunedin last Friday because bus companies refused to take her motorised wheelchair.

Bus companies' three main reasons were driver safety lifting the wheelchair, space restrictions, and the potential hazard of the batteries, Wellington woman Trish Harris said.

Ms Harris and a group of friends undertook the Otago Central Rail Trail between Middlemarch and Clyde, where Ms Harris intended leaving her friends.

She said four bus companies informed her, either by phone or on their website, that she could not take her motorised wheelchair on their vehicles.

She contacted directly Atomic Shuttles and Dunedin City Council-owned Connexions Bus Services to address the concerns.

"I was hoping if I sorted these things they would take me."

She had friends at both ends of her trip to lift the wheelchair on and off the vehicle, and the services did not look particularly full, she said.

Air New Zealand transported her dry cell batteries, she said.

Because she could not get on a bus, friends heading to Christchurch diverted to Dunedin on Friday where she was to visit a friend.

Ms Harris returns to Wellington today.

Ms Harris can walk about 50m before needing a rest.

She preferred not to name her disability.

New Zealand Transport Agency spokesman Andy Knackstedt said restrictions on batteries only applied to air travel.

"So in all circumstances of transport on land, electric wheelchairs are not subject to controls for transport as dangerous goods."

Bus companies were not obliged to take disabled people under law, he said.

Connexions general manager Tony Collins maintained the company required a Hazardous Goods Licence to carry the batteries.

"From a company policy perspective, this is the carriage of freight for which both hazardous substances regulations and health and safety regulations need to be complied with."

Also, it was uncertain whether the wheelchair would fit in the vehicle, and whether Ms Harris' friends would definitely be available to lift the chair.

Under the company's policy, it could not make a booking if there was any uncertainty, Mr Collins said.

Atomic Shuttles co-owner Peter Robertson denied Ms Harris offered her friends' help to lift the wheelchair.

An older driver was on duty for whom lifting the wheelchair was out of the question, Mr Robertson said.

Also, the shuttle did not have space.

Intercity sales and marketing manager Daniel Rode said the bus company could not take the batteries due to the hazardous materials they might contain.

 

Overseas they have...

Overseas they have hundreds of thousands of patrons using the service, so they can afford to run bigger, more spacious buses.

Fair Go

I cannot believe all this stuff about hazardous batteries. I cannot believe that the the south cannot transport those with electric wheelchairs. What do they do overseas?

Buses and space

It is said that this lady was unable to use the buses for the between Clyde & Dunedin. Being a frequent bus user I can confirm that these buses are very small and don't have a lot of room for luggage let alone a motorised wheelchair. Thinking of Atomic Shuttles and Intercity Bus services there is no way that the wheelchair would fit onto the bus with the people or under the bus with the luggage. Also with the Connexions Bus the same applies. There is no way that it would fit onto the bus - possibly it might have been able to go into the narrow boot with the luggage on top of it - however that would have meant unpacking & re-packing all luggage collected between Queenstown & Clyde which would not be an easy task. This is a sad situation and if it had happened to someone where the wheelchair could have been easily folded or dismantied then it would have been objectionable. However sometimes life is not fair.

The lack of initiative that OSH caused

It is a sad commentary on how bureaucracy robs a Southern community of individuals with the strength of character and the initiative to provide a solution to a problem. The fact of the matter is that the OSH bureaucratic juggernaut has made us all afraid to think outside the box and come up with a solution, for fear that we will get "potted" by a competitor, and face the prospect of crippling fines, and ruination of the business. Poetic justice that it was someone from Wellington that was on the receiving end eh. Sad that she has been left feeling that it was the local community that let her down, and most importantly revealing that the real culprit lacks the courage to admit culpability in any way shape or form, with a dry bureaucratic spin on the facts to justify the act it administers..