Nevis oil plan prompts concerns

An environmental timebomb is ticking in the Nevis Valley.

A London-based mining company, Xtract Energy Plc, has been granted a mineral exploration permit covering 10,450ha of the Nevis Valley in Central Otago, including the Nevis, Bannockburn and Lorn survey districts.

Crown Minerals group manager Richard Garlick granted the five-year permit to Xtract Energy Plc, which also has a base in Australia, on May 25, 2007.

The permit gives Xtract exclusive rights to explore and test for oil shale, and permission to perform a follow-up programme involving the drilling of at least 15 holes.

Because the permit was for exploration only, no resource consent was required from the Otago Regional Council or the Central Otago District Council.

However, Central Otago Mayor Malcolm Macpherson said a resource consent application would be "enormously controversial" should the company wish to start mining oil shale.

Oil shaleFine-grained sedimentary rock, containing the tarry compound kerogen, which can be processed to extract hydrocarbons (used as fuels).

Xtract Energy is investigating a new Australian-developed technology to extract the oil from shale in enclosed vessels.

Nevis has been investigated previously, but was economically marginal.

Oil shale is found near the surface, but drilling is required as a quality control to ensure the shale on the surface is of the same quality as shale found deeper.

Xtract Australian asset management director Dr John Shirley told the Mountain Scene "hundreds of millions of tonnes" of oil shale was believed to be in the Nevis, which could lead to a "multibillion-dollar development" in the area.

Gaining resource consent for a development of that scale would likely divide the district. Dr Macpherson said two processes could be used to extract oil shale, should testing be favourable.

The drilling of holes would not require "too much" surface disturbance.

"That wouldn't be terribly difficult to consent," Dr Macpherson said.

"However, if they wanted to strip mine . . . if anyone ever proposed that, it would beenormously controversial."

Professor Dave Craw, of the University of Otago's geology department, said the Nevis was part of the coal-bearing strata found all through Central Otago.

Oil exploration

Nice post. I got many ideas. I will visit this site again if there are new improvements.

No oil exploration in the Nevis Valley

I am very concerned by your recent article suggesting that large-scale mining of oil shale in the Nevis Valley could be under way soon. Producing oil from oil shale is the most inefficient form of oil exploration because it requires heating the sand-oil mixture to the point that the oil becomes sufficiently liquid so it can be separated from the minerals. This process requires large amounts of energy, probably coming from burning the oil itself. It also involves digging through large areas of remote wilderness, turning them into industrial wasteland. Then there is the associated infrastructure, lorry- or pipeline-based transport of oil, possibly spills into local waterways. All of this in one of the most picturesque and untouched corners of the South Island. In the face of global climate change we should invest into sustainable energy projects, for which there is ample potential in this area, instead of holding on to our fossil fuel addiction for as long as we possibly can. New Zealand has a reputation as a progressive, environmentally sensitive country; this project runs diametrically against those values and would represent the most repulsive victory for Big Oil against common sense. We know that we cannot keep digging up carbon and blasting it into the atmosphere; doing so will render this planet uninhabitable for our children. Yet when the riches are found on our doorsteps, we seem to put our conscience to one side. So my hope is that those responsible for the decision will take those objections into consideration.