Board wants campervan ban

Campervans would no longer be seen on New Zealand roads if the Otago Conservation Board has its way. Photo by Gerard O'Brien.
Campervans would no longer be seen on New Zealand roads if the Otago Conservation Board has its way. Photo by Gerard O'Brien.
The Otago Conservation Board wants a national ban on the use of campervans and will lobby the Government to get its way.

However, opponents of the fledgling movement have labelled calls for the blanket ban "ridiculous" and "absolute lunacy".

Freedom campers have been condemned frequently by community leaders for the mess and human waste they leave on roadsides and at scenic parking spots around the Queenstown Lakes district and Otago.

Discussions during a meeting of the Otago Conservation Board at Tarras yesterday centred around the issue of freedom campers, the mess they create and the companies that rent campervans to tourists.

Board member David Holdsworth, of Portobello, said the companies renting freedom campervans to tourists needed to take some responsibility for the mess their customers created.

He called for a licensing scheme which would make the rental companies responsible for the actions of those who hired campervans.

Residents and ratepayers were the ones who picked up the bill for travellers and the mess they left behind in local communities.

Andrew Penniket, of Wanaka, took a more severe approach.

He called for a national ban on campervans.

Freedom campers contributed "very little" to local and regional communities.

"They spend hardly anything, anywhere," he said.

Rental companies were mainly foreign-owned, with profits going overseas; and the vehicles clogged up the country's roads and highways, he said.

"Personally, I'd ban campervans altogether from New Zealand.

"The whole country would be better off without them," Mr Penniket said.

Automobile Association tourism head Peter Blackwell said a general call to ban campervans in New Zealand was "absolute lunacy".

Calling for such a blanket ban was "ignorant and nonsensical" and would affect New Zealand's tourism industry, he said.

However, more could be done when travellers arrived and hired campervans to make them aware of New Zealanders' expectations, Mr Blackwell said.

Australian-based Wicked Campervans director John Webb said the move was "ridiculous".

"Any attempt to outlaw campervans would have a disastrous impact on the nation's tourism industry."

Kiwi camping holidays

My family and I are Kiwis and have had many good camping holidays. Shouldn't you leave your campsite in better condition than you found it? At least its something we have done and taught our kids to do. We have found waste material human and other left by both tourists and Kiwis - something does need done to be. Broken glass from beer bottles is another problem we have found every where we go.
Two possible solutions for the human waste issue 1/The provision of pay toilets placed in the right spots. As someone pointed out they have in the UK seem to me to be a great idea for human waste problem.
2/ Porta toilets and dump stations which are a little work but work ok. The glass problem is mostly a kiwi one and after having to clean up many sites so as we could camp there safely just leaves you feeling annoyed and discusted. The people who leave broken glass seem to be lacking something in my view.
Providing affordable solutions may be a better answer instead of more rules on top of the ones we already have that don't work. I would like to continue camping in NZ with my family. Let's hope we can find reasonable solutions which would see Kiwi families able to continue to do so.

Pay toilets

I do not think banning is the answer. However, obviously something needs to be done. What about toilets in rest areas with slots to pay (say 20 cents) as they do in the UK. This might stop some of the waste being left (which is disgusting and I can understand people's anger)

Let's target only the problem campers - not campervans

Here in Omarama with our lakeside camps and river walks etc., we also have the ongoing problem with human waste. However these issues do not arise from either the responsible NZMCA members who own campers or buses, nor is it from the majority of the thousands of tourist-rental campervans such as Maui etc. - as you know, these are fully self-contained on board. I also take extreme issue with the Board's ridiculous comment that these people do not spend. What is that based upon?
I would be absolutely amazed if any retailer, café or business in NZ would agree with that. We have been a retailer in Omarama for over 10 years and in that time have seen the huge business and money that the campervan business (both NZers and international tourists) brings to the community and the entire country - the majority of whom are entirely responsible. 99% of the toileting issues arise from the wagons and minivans, and the private vans, cars and travellers (including huge numbers of New Zealanders) who choose not to take the responsible route by hiring a vehicle with self-contained facilities or by walking or driving to a public toilet from their site.
Every year over Christmas and New Year we have groups who freedom camp down by the Ahuriri River. DOC has done a great job of putting in a free toilet facility beside the bridge on the reserve just out of Omarama, yet we still find tissue and waste within a few hundred metres of the facility. 
Wherever possible we must provide education and maps showing where facilities are, if possible more facilities, and also policing (such as the early morning calls made by the Queenstown and Wanaka District Councils).
Let's take the positive and solution based route rather than bashing the majority for a problem caused by a particular sector.
[Abridged]

Campervans

New Zealand is our home. My husband and I are looking forward to retirement in a few years, when we plan to motorhome around NZ. We have hired motorhomes in the past and have thoroughly enjoyed the experience. All the waste is contained within the motorhome, so we take nothing from the places we stay at, and we leave nothing behind.

Do we need to make a distinction between campervans and motorhomes? Campervans do not have bathrooms inside of them. So, what do they do? The people who use campervans would I am sure, use rubbish bins and toilets if they were available along their traveling route. However, our experience is that they are not.

After driving for miles, a roadsign alerts us to a picnic area, but alas, there is no picnic table, no rubbish bin and certainly no toilet. Wouldn't this be the place to start for the Otago Conservation Board, to improve facilties at picnic areas and laybys, and to offer freedom campers solutions instead of banning them?

In France, they set aside specific areas for campervan parking at no cost!

A little sanity, please.

What a knee-jerk reaction - penalise the majority for the misbehaviour of a minority! Obviously there is room for improvement in the behaviour of some campers, but it would be more realistic to look at areas of education, regulation, 'policing' and 'on-the spot' penalties for transgressions. (And more public facilities?) All countries have to deal with this burgeoning style of tourism so we just have to take a reasonable attitude - not shoot from the hip!

Freedom campers

I am a member of the NZMCA and am currently in the Otago District. David Holdsworth is incorrect when he says we spend hardly anything. At the very least we need to buy food and fuel.

However, I have to agree with some aspects of the article. We travel in a self-contained vehicle and would never leave human waste anywhere in the environment. We also pick up rubbish left by people in hire campers and young people from the particular district we are in. Most campervanners I know do the same.

We do bring a lot of revenue to the areas we visit but, unfortunately. if you want people coming into your district and spending money you will have rubbish. There is no getting away from that.

I believe that hire campers should all be self contained. Or they should be required to park in areas where there are toilet facilities.

There are some people who are really anti-campervanners and that is totally illogical. This is a huge part of the tourist industy. Dont throw the baby out with the bath water.

National campervan ban

Oh my God ... You must surely be joking. I read this article (and after I stopped laughing hysterically) realised a few things:
1. A national ban on campervans will not only impact the companies that hire them out and the companies that build them, but also the NZ economy. Goodbye to the tourist dollar :( 
2. Let's just hope that in the extremely slim chance that this proposed ban does go through, Mr. Penniket doesn't intend on taking his family on holiday - with no campervans, it's a bloody long walk carrying camping gear and stuff.

[Abridged]

Campervans - sensible planning required

I've discussed this a lot with friends as this has ramifications for the tramping community. The biggest problem with these campervans are those that don't have their own toilet facilities. There should be a plan put in place to cease issuing WOFs to such vehicles within 5 years.

Some of these vehicles are just big cars and only the most diligent of users will avoid a big impact on the environment around them when inhabiting them for 2 weeks or more. On the other hand people going for a weekend tramp need to be able to use a fly / put a tent down / sleep in a shelter at the road end for a few hours on a Friday night. This kind of freedom camping, provided it is done responsibly has little / no impact. Continued education and good practice in the outdoor community is required.