
The owners of this award-winning property in Wānaka faced a difficult decision — whether to renovate the 1970s house on the site or build a new one in its place.
While there were many things about the house they liked, it also had some shortcomings, one of the owners says, adding they wanted to have a warm house and would have struggled to bring it up to the Building Code.

"There were quite a lot of issues with [the old house] but there was a lovely feel about it, which amazingly has sort of been transferred to this [new] one," she says.
"The old house had courtyards and garden areas that [wrapped around it] and we have that here."
"Big book shelves, sunny window seats and things like that have been repeated as well."

The architects say while there was strong emotional attachment to the original house, the building was no longer fit for purpose.
"It was modest in scale, poorly insulated and lacked the thermal performance required for year-round comfort in Wānaka’s climate. Renovating would have required significant structural and thermal upgrades, and ultimately wouldn’t have achieved the long-term vision the clients had for a warm, efficient home that could welcome extended family."
Surrounded by mature oak trees, the four-bedroom house is composed of two main pavilions arranged in a split-level plan to respond to the site’s contours.

The bedroom wing is set slightly lower, creating a subtle separation in scale and experience while maintaining a cohesive whole.
Sustainability was key, with passive design principles ensuring energy efficiency. A high-performance thermal envelope, heat recovery ventilation and photovoltaics reduce the home’s environmental impact.

Although they encountered asbestos when they pulled the old house down and Covid lockdowns later, the process was stress-free, the owner says.
"It was excellent working with the architects and we were also very lucky with the building company [Breen Construction]."
While the house has several hard surfaces, including concrete floors and a board-formed concrete wall, a timber-lined acoustic ceiling works well to soften reverberation, she adds.

They were also pleased to find their initial concerns that the new house could stand out too much were unfounded. Enveloped by garden, it is similar to the original in that it’s "tucked in" and unobtrusive.
That aspect was also praised by the judges when the project received an award in the 2025 Southern Architecture Awards.

"In a location often bound by attempts to capture expansive mountain views, the house provides a refreshing contrast by nestling itself into the established landscape."