Physio pool’s fate to become clearer

The Dunedin Physio Pool’s heat exchanger failed in May and the pool has not been open since....
The Dunedin Physio Pool’s heat exchanger failed in May and the pool has not been open since. PHOTO: ALLIED PRESS FILES

The future of the Dunedin Physio Pool is expected to become less murky when the Southern District Health Board  meets next week. 

Failure of the pool’s heat exchanger in May this year was one of several issues which caused a ‘‘perfect financial storm’’ for the Otago Therapeutic Pool Trust, and left trustees questioning whether the pool could remain open beyond this year. 

The SDHB and the trust have been in discussions about what remedial work is required and the associated financial issues, before the pool can reopen. 

The board is expected to discuss the issues at its meeting in Invercargill on Tuesday next week. 

Trust secretary-treasurer Neville Martin said the trust had asked the SDHB if it would grant a waiver of part of the contribution towards the cost of running the pool. 

‘‘At the moment, the trust pays the SDHB $142,000, and we’re suggesting that the board waive $100,000 of that for a year once the pool reopens.’’ 

If the board waived the running costs, the trust could continue to run the pool, he said. 

The SDHB was also expected to make a decision soon on whether it would help pay for the repair or replacement of the failed pool equipment. 

‘‘Whatever the decisions are post-August 3, they will certainly clarify a number of uncertainties at the moment. 

‘‘There are a number of big issues that need to be resolved and it’s just a matter of making sure that they are resolved in an orderly manner. 

‘‘And we certainly don’t want to reopen the pool when we don’t have the proper equipment and we don’t know whether we can afford to keep going and keep it open.’’ 

The trust took the pool over in 2014, when the SDHB had wanted to close it, Mr Martin said. 

It was on the understanding the trust would be responsible for all operating costs ($142,000 per year), deferred maintenance and replacement of equipment. 

A Save the Pool campaign began in 2015 and raised $1 million for pool upgrades and $500,000 for future operating costs and contingencies. 

Funding for upgrades was sought from usual funding providers by way of conditional grants and the target was reached. 

However, at the end of 2015, the SDHB announced it would not grant a long-term lease of the pool because it might need the space for a new clinical services building. This issue morphed into a new hospital. 

As a consequence, the pool upgrade project had to be postponed indefinitely and the conditional offers of grants were recalled. 

Recently, the trust entered into a memorandum of understanding with the SDHB, which said the trust would have use of the pool until 2028 if it continued to be responsible for all operating costs, deferred maintenance and replacement of equipment. 

Since 2015, the trust had been ‘‘stymied’’ in its plans to upgrade the pool and reduce operating costs, and had to wait for the decision to be made about the location of the new hospital and adhere to the existing cost structure. 

This forced the trust to incur annual operating deficits, he said.

To fund these, the trust had to obtain grants and use much of its reserves and the funds given by the public during the Save the Pool campaign. 

While the pool was able to remain open, the condition of its facilities had deteriorated, he said. 

‘‘In addition, the delay and the uncertainty about whether the pool would be affected by the location of the new hospital, and the inability to carry out upgrades and reduce operating costs, have taken their toll on the trust’s reserves, to the extent that it is questionable whether the pool should remain open beyond this year without intervention from either the SDHB or a major funding boost.’’ 






Many working women and men use this pool as well as the physically challenged and some stroke and brain injured patients . Why wouldnt our health system pay when the benefits are so many? Why is it we common people have to beg for our mental health and well being facilities. Every day we are bombarded with new mental health initiatives full of words but no actual action of providing the well being to its citizens. It is unconscionable that this is even a discussion when we give the elite of the community an umbrellad football field, costing millions. I am beyond outraged that the forgotten sector of our community is left to beg for a facility that gives so many hope.

The Dhb has want to he rid of the pool for decades and the public has stopped them. this time they thought they had got away with it but then the trust was formed and they couldn't without public seeing through the charade.
Whats really stupid is that at 100k running costs a year and around 40k of user sessions a year it was costing the DHB less than 3 dollars a session for either rehab or as preventive rehab . With the age groups and conditions catered for this was likely one of the most, if not the most cost effective program the dhb ran when it comes to cost vs outcomes



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter