Muscularity challenges feminine ideal

Why are we so afraid of strong, muscular women, Jamillla Rosdahl, a lecturer in gender studies at the University of Sunshine Coast, asks.

Tennis champion Serena Williams lets her prowess do the talking in debate about body image....
Tennis champion Serena Williams lets her prowess do the talking in debate about body image. Photos by Reuters.
We don't see many muscular women in popular culture - and the display of much heavier and obviously stronger female bodies can be overwhelming or shocking.

Professional tennis-playing sisters Serena and Venus Williams, who are in Australia for the summer tennis season, are good examples of female athletes who have received much negative attention for their ''thicker'' arms and heavier-set, muscular bodies.

Other examples include retired world champion bodybuilder Bev Francis and South African middle-distance runner Caster Semenya. They have all been criticised for having bodies that cannot possibly belong to real women.

Why are we so afraid of strong, muscular women?

After all, there is nothing unnatural about a strong and muscular woman. What's unnatural is preventing and discouraging women from reaching their full physical potential in the name of femininity.

Muscle is associated with male bodies and therefore with masculinity.

Muscularity is not linked to displays of womanhood or ideas about femaleness. Therefore, a muscular woman does not conform to acceptable codes of femininity.

A muscular woman challenges what it means to be a ''real'' woman or a ''real'' man. It challenges the assumption that all men are big, strong and powerful and that all women are smaller, weaker and dependent. A muscular woman can be wildly perplexing.

Muscular women are often accused of taking steroids, being deviant, sexually confused or deliberately trying to offend others. They are frequently told they are unattractive, man-haters, selfish mothers or transvestites. They are charged as having either too much testosterone or too little femininity.

On the other hand, we associate muscle with male-dominated sports such as bodybuilding. Bodybuilding is culturally coded as almost exclusively male. Men compete and are judged solely on their muscularity. Their muscular bodies are compared on symmetry, muscular form, size, development and overall presentation.

Unlike male bodybuilding, women who compete in body sculpting are required to minimise their muscularity. Body sculpting or body figure competition is a sport that only women can compete in. It is also a sport where the contradiction of muscle and femininity is most obvious.

Many women train long and gruelling hours to become strong and muscular - only to be told on competition day that they are not feminine enough. In contrast to men's bodybuilding, femininity is part of the women's judging criteria.

Iris Kyle, of California, performs her routine on the way to winning the Ms International...
Iris Kyle, of California, performs her routine on the way to winning the Ms International heavyweight finals at the Arnold Fitness Weekend in Columbus, Ohio, in 2004.
Competitors are told to emphasise femininity, symmetry, proportion, tone and definition and to minimise physique and muscle mass.

They are also expected to display graceful gestures and soft movements and have an hourglass figure. They have to wear make-up, heels and revealing and sparkling bikinis. Judges have even been found selecting women who are big-busted, pretty and slim and whose muscles are not visible unless flexed.

Femininity is linked to a female body that is slender, neat and sexually attractive. Because the muscular female form is so challenging, sports such as body sculpting use femininity as a buffer to counter the fact that women also have muscle (we do not judge male bodybuilders on their masculinity, their ''maleness'').

When female athletes train and use their bodies as men do, women become muscular and strong, too. Femininity prevents us from accepting muscle on women.

The problem is not muscle. The problem is femininity itself. Ideas about womanhood make muscular women appear unnatural. Femininity normalises a female body that is round, soft, small and heterosexually appealing.

Because femininity cannot be located within the body, most women have to display it on their bodies. This performance is achieved by minimising muscularity, clothing choice, make-up, hairstyles and attending to grooming and nails.

Femininity dictates what women can do with their bodies and there are grave social consequences for not conforming.

The result? Women operate within a restricted space.

Being thin, weak or helpless does not allow full physical capacity. Indeed, women train their bodies to be inefficient. They become disconnected from their bodies, losing power and strength. This results in a distrust of their bodies, capabilities and an overall sense of insecurity. This affects how women experience relationships, how they carry themselves and relate to others.

While we are seeing a cultural shift from an emphasis on thinness to a more toned and athletic female body, many girls and women are still preoccupied with diet and weight loss - and there is still a fear of women being muscular and bulky.

Let us start thinking differently about women with muscle.

Women who care for their bodies through physical exercise become healthy, strong and capable. Ideas such as ''real women are thin and weak'', are a bit like smoking: eventually, people will catch on that it just is not good for you.

- the

Add a Comment

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter