Motels are empty but bills keep coming in

Up to half of the motels across the region are "teetering on the edge of financial collapse", the Otago Motel Association has estimated.

Association president Alex Greenan said whether motels were open or closed, they had ongoing costs like rates, electricity and rent.

"Even though we’re empty, the costs are still there.

"Rent is the big one."

He said there were about 200 motel owners across Otago, and most of them leased their buildings from landlords.

About a third of a motel owner’s income went straight to paying the rent.

He said some leases stated if there were no occupants, the motel owner did not have to pay rent — but some motels had had to remain open to accommodate essential workers during the Covid-19 pandemic.

"So they’ve had dribs and drabs, maybe the odd nurse or Winz person that needs help.

"But the income from it is minuscule. It doesn’t pay the rent. But they’re open, so therefore, they can’t apply for [no occupancy] ... to get out of paying the rent."

Mr Greenan believed about 50% of landlords around Dunedin were helping their tenants by cutting their rental fees.

"We appreciate that because they’ve got costs, too.

"But a lot of landlords are not coming to the party. I’ve been speaking to some members who are in tears because they’re not getting good communication with their landlords.

"Some landlords have told their tenants, point blank, to suck it up.

"About 90% of Dunedin motel owners are suffering financial difficulty and a significant number are teetering on the edge of financial collapse."

Mr Greenan believed owners in other parts of the region would be similarly affected.

The Dunedin City Council could help the situation in Dunedin by providing rates relief to motel owners, he said.

He said the council was expected to meet at the end of the month to discuss the issue, but believed it should have been done sooner.

"It’s not next month we need some help — it’s right now."

Many motel owners would have to borrow money to survive until next month, he said.

"And next month is going to be bad, too. So what are you going to do? At what point do you walk away, which is what we are all looking at?"

Dunedin Mayor Aaron Hawkins was unable to be reached for comment yesterday.

In Invercargill, 295 on Tay Motel owner Geoff Shepherd said the situation was very similar in Southland.

"It’s very hard down here, too."

It was estimated there were about 20 motels in Invercargill and up to 60 across the region.



"So they’ve had dribs and drabs, maybe the odd nurse or Winz person that needs help", from what i have read these places are charging winz clients $3000 upwards a week (and it is more than "the odd winz person") and yet they are crying poor?.
"The Dunedin City Council could help the situation in Dunedin by providing rates relief to motel owners", the dcc could provide us all with rates relief and not borrow to close the main street.

Perfect time from next week for many of the motel providers to refurbish the accommodation from an outdated 1970's look and feel. Don't tell me there is no money. The occupancy has been good in Dunedin I am sure as there is limited choices. Like all business owners this needs to be looked at as an opportunity and to carry out work which can be difficult and inconvenient under a normal working environment. Get stuck and bring Dunedin up to date and our family looks forward to coming to Dunedin as soon as it is possible to come and watch some rugby!

I've heard this story before.

Happy to rake it in while times are great, but expect taxpayers and ratepayers to bail you out when the going gets tough.

So it's okay to raid our pockets now, is it? Okay to grab what we earn? Help yourself to our pockets?

You weren't offering locals any discounts when we wanted to stay in your hotels or motels, were you?

I can't find any sympathies. I really wish I could, but I can't. I know you're hurting, but we are too.

You're on your own. But if you pull through this, maybe you'll be a bit more respectful of your countrymen, and a bit kinder to families and retirees who are the lifeblood of this country.





Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter