Comment permalink

Blair Vining hands his petition to former Clutha-Southland National MP Hamish Walker. PHOTOS: SUPPLIED, LUISA GIRAO, HEALTH SELECT COMMITTEE, TIM ONNES
 Pauline Latta presents her 
petition to Labour Taieri 
MP Ingrid Leary.
Pauline Latta presents her petition to Labour Taieri MP Ingrid Leary.
Joshua Perry 
speaks in support of his 
petition to the health select 
Joshua Perry speaks in support of his petition to the health select committee.
Green list MP 
Chloe Swarbrick accepts 
Corinda Taylor’s petition.
Green list MP Chloe Swarbrick accepts Corinda Taylor’s petition.

Cynics have been known to scoff that the go-to solution for a politician faced with a problem is to form a committee.

Among the many problems Parliament faces is what to do with all the petitions it receives, and lo and behold it has formed a committee to deal with it.

Parliament receives a lot of petitions - more than 190 are listed as presented and awaiting reporting back to the House, with a further 103 recently closed for signatures and 106 still accepting names.

That represents not just the individual concerns of those petitioners, but also those of the people who took the trouble to sign.

Some petitions have just a few signatures but, to take just one example, the recently closed petition of former Queenstown chef Ryann Lourenco calling for residence status for all migrants currently on temporary work visas has more than 64,000.

Very roughly, that number of signatures equates to about the number of votes cast in one and a-half electorates last election; if Parliament chose to ignore a petition of that size — and it has yet to consider Mr Lourenco’s — it would do so with some degree of political risk.

It is standard practice for any petition presented to Parliament to be referred to a select committee.

However, those bodies are busy scrutinising legislation and auditing government organisations as well, and it can take quite some time for petitions to work their way through the system: several have waited since 2019 or even earlier to be reported back.

To its credit, Parliament recognised this was not good enough, and that incredibly important issues were sitting gathering dust in its to-do pile.

To name a few, still to be reported back are the petition of Dunedin mother and Life Matters Suicide Prevention Trust founder Corinda Taylor for better access to justice for suicide-bereaved families and whanau; the late Winton farmer Blair Vining’s petitions calling for better cancer care; and Dunedin man Joshua Perry’s one asking for a better process for housing modification for disabled people.

Last year’s review of Parliament’s standing orders recommended the establishment of a petitions select committee to hopefully expedite their progress.

All petitions now stand referred to the petitions committee for consideration.

That said, if it sees fit it can send a petition to a specialist select committee — for example, when the committee comes to Dunedin woman Pauline Latta’s 50,000-signature petition calling for the Government to fully fund the St John ambulance service, it might decide it would be better considered by the health select committee.

Any referred petition remains the responsibility of the petitions committee, and must receive "timely consideration".

Jacqui Dean
Jacqui Dean

It can also refer a petition directly to a minister.

Like any select committee, it can ask for submissions from the petitioner and interested parties, but is not required to ask for public submissions — a stage which has bogged down many a petition in the past, but which many would also argue is vital.

The committee will report back on all petitions, and any recommendations to the Government must be responded to.

Waitaki MP Jacqui Dean, as chairwoman of the committee, is the parliamentarian charged with alleviating the gridlock.

The six-member committee, which includes Labour Invercargill list MP Liz Craig, met on Thursday with six petitions on its agenda.

Given the number of petitions and signatories awaiting developments, its progress is sure to be keenly observed.

Getting in early

Liz Craig
Liz Craig

Rachel Brooking’s maiden speech was pushed back by a day to Wednesday, but the newly elected Dunedin Labour list MP managed to pipe up sooner.

Ms Brooking, an environmental lawyer prior to politics, was given the chance earlier that day to ask Question 7, about reform of the Resource Management Act ... something she knows more than a little about, given she was on the committee appointed by the Government to consider possible reforms of the legislation.

He rides again, and again

Dunedin National Party list MP Michael Woodhouse got an early taste on Wednesday of what looks sure to be a long-running joke this session.

Quizzed by Mr Woodhouse on the percentage rise in the cost of core government services, Finance Minister Grant Robertson replied: "I would need to check those figures because, perhaps unlike the arrival of a homeless man in a hotel, we always have to check these things out."

Mr Woodhouse — who did indeed once raise the possibility that a homeless man had slipped into a Covid-19 managed isolation facility — will no doubt have noted that the question was dodged and be seeking further, humour-free and figure-full answers in the future.


Far too many petitions are based on emotion getting in the way of facts. Many are poorly worded.
Pauline Latta has been used as a mule by St John to “get them fully funded”. Pauline has been told but she, the news media and public don’t get it – St John puts in for commercial tenders to provide the ambulance service in each DHB area. You can’t put in for a cheap contract or accept a low tender then cry charity. The Govt cannot top up after a contract for any private organisation. St John cannot be “fully funded” therefore. Now if the petition said “we want a fully funded Govt run ambulance service” then that would fly - and in fact that’s what the Govt is waiting for - public support. But while you have the Paulines of this world who can’t see past the Venerable Order of . . . yawn.
When starting a petition, do homework first, accept advice second.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter