Riff review awards reporter tough praise

Starry-eyed and opinionated reviewer Tim Scott. PHOTO: CHRISTINE O’CONNOR
Starry-eyed and opinionated reviewer Tim Scott. PHOTO: CHRISTINE O’CONNOR
Getting the story sometimes means getting out of your comfort zone. Five of our excellent cadets recount the stories that affected them as reporters at the Otago Daily Times

As a journalist, it is to be expected that those you criticise will be quick to rebut.

However, I never expected a national comedian would turn my own words against me.

Let me explain.

It was the middle of March, the Dunedin’s Fringe Festival was in full flight and theatre-goers had lined Princes St scouring for some chutzpah to get themselves a-chortling.

As a starry-eyed and opinionated young buck, eager to pave my way into the world of reviewing, being invited to review Guy Williams: Comedy Plus Time Equals Tragedy was an opportunity I jumped at.

I met up with a mate and we strapped in for what had been pitched as a no-holds-barred Williams, let off the leash at last.

During the show, Williams declared something along the lines of, "I hope there’s no reviewers in the audience tonight."

I would soon discover comedy plus time does indeed equal a tragedy.

Auckland comedian Guy Williams, who is performing at the Dunedin Fringe Festival. PHOTO: SUPPLIED
Auckland comedian Guy Williams, who is performing at the Dunedin Fringe Festival. PHOTO: SUPPLIED
Overall the show was a bit underwhelming — my mate described it as "painfully average" — but I left satisfied I had enough material for a robust review.

A few days after publication, my flatmate broke the news to me.

He had worked as a sound technician for the festival and said Williams had pilfered my review, referencing it in his last show.

What, I hear you ask, had attracted the attention of a seasoned veteran of the country’s comedy sphere?

It was the headline: "Comedian riffs on issues, hates Dunedin."

My review was a classic compliment sandwich, wrapped around one meaty slice of blunt criticism, but I was perplexed as to what all the fuss was about.

While I never pinpointed Williams’ precise beef with my review, he later reposted it on social media with a caption that made his feelings abundantly clear.

"Best review of my life."

In the post, he assured New Zealand he did not really hate Dunedin and it was just a joke, which given it was in fact a "comedy" show, you would hope had been clear.

Whether or not this was all a part of the gag — Williams later admitting his first show "was a bit av my bad that was my fault" — the incident soon became just another story in my catalogue.

But as far as praise goes, I don’t think I could wish for anything better.