Call for UK media to stop naming murder-accused

Andrew Little
Andrew Little

New Zealand's Justice Minister says UK media naming the man accused of murdering British backpacker Grace Millane is potentially jeopardising a fair trial, which could heap more misery on her family.

The 22-year-old woman had been missing for a week and her body was found in bush in the Auckland's Waitakere Ranges on Sunday.

A 26-year-old man appeared in the Auckland District Court yesterday and was granted interim name suppression. 

Justice Minister Andrew Little told media this morning it was "unfortunate the British papers have done what they’ve done.

"It will not do justice to the Millane family if the accused in this case gets to walk away from facing justice because somebody else has disclosed his details."

The naming of the man, which has also happened in social media, could be used to argue that he won’t get a fair trial, Little said.

“The defence counsel will be looking for every opportunity to say fair trial rights might be compromised. The guy at some point will face court and potentially a trial in New Zealand.

“If he doesn’t, and he gets to walk away, that’s a further injustice to the Millane family.”

Yesterday, defence lawyer Ian Brookie sought interim name suppression for his client based on fair trial rights, which was opposed by police, the Millane family and the press.

Judge Evangelos Thomas declined the application for name suppression, but Brookie appealed the decision, which automatically imposes a 20 working day suppression under New Zealand law.

Little issued a stern warning, but acknowledged that British media were outside the jurisdiction of New Zealand courts.

“The international media, particularly the British media, are not helping the Millane family. If the media are concerned about justice and doing justice for the Millane family, they should stop publishing details.

“We don’t have any arrangement whereby we can stop media from overseas publishing information. What we can do is act as tightly as we can here.”

Yesterday, Detective Inspector Scott Beard, of Auckland City Police, reminded the public that the 26-year-old had interim name suppression.

It followed numerous breaches of the suppression ruling yesterday, with the man’s name and image being repeatedly posted and shared on social media.

“We would like to remind the public that whilst we appreciate the public feeling around this case, it is an offence to breach a court order such as a name suppression, and this includes naming someone who has name suppression on social media," Det Insp Beard.

National leader Simon Bridges, a former Crown prosecutor, said suppression orders had a place but would not go as far as asking British media to stop naming the accused.

He said the case was “very affecting”.

“Having worked on cases that have some similarities to these, I know what an affect they have on the family involved. For a father to have to come out here to a foreign land very far away, it’s heart-wrenching.

“All New Zealanders will feel deeply for them and be moved by this case.”

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern became emotional at her press conference yesterday as she apologised to the Millane family on behalf of the country, saying that Grace Millane should have been safe in New Zealand.

Little echoed that sentiment this morning.

“When a young woman, really on the cusp of the future of her life, is snuffed out in the way Grace Millane has been, we’re all going to appalled by it, ashamed that it happened in our country.”

He said the Government was tackling New Zealand’s issues of family violence and violence against women.

“We’ve got to fix that problem. It underpins a whole heap of problems that we’ve got.

“We’ve seen another victim of it, and a visitor to our shores.”


No they should name the low life new Zealand should name him also.....but we are ruled by flakes