Shaw apologises for 'error of judgement' over school funding

Greens co-leader James Shaw said the decision to support the funding of a private green school in Tarakanki "was an error of judgement" and he has apologised for it.

He said today that the mistake wasn't one that would warrant his resignation as co-leader. However, he admitted there was a risk that the Green Party wouldn't make it back into Parliament.

Shaw, who is Associate Finance Minister, has met with a variety of organisations, including schools groups and unions, saying he's taken the time to reflect on their concerns and to act on them.

His comments come following days of criticism from the Greens' voter bases, as well as the National Party, over the fact the private school got $11.7 million.

Shaw said every dollar of the $3 billion fund was spent to create jobs and one of the sectors most at risk from the downturn was infrastructure and construction. He said this had knock-on effects for the local community.

The minister said when the mayor of New Plymouth first told him about the Greens School, he saw an opportunity to support a green infrastructure economy.

Shaw said it was "a fair question" to ask why the money was going to a private construction project when so many public schools were run-down and mouldy.

 

Greens co-leader James Shaw. Photo: NZ Herald
Greens co-leader James Shaw. Photo: NZ Herald

He said this was why the Government had invested in school infrastructure late last year, but it was apparent this money wasn't getting into schools fast enough. He said their decades-long commitment to public education hadn't changed.

Shaw said progress towards a better future demanded tough choices and not every choice would be the right one, and for that Shaw apologised again.

He understands that representatives of the Green School had approached the Crown to work on a solution, but ministers couldn't be seen to interfere with this.

Shaw said his preference was for the money to be provided as a loan to ensure the money would be paid back in full in the future.

There is a contracting relationship in place between the school and the Crown, and Shaw said it wouldn't be appropriate as a minister to go into the details of that.

Shaw said the mayor was quite clear he wanted the project to proceed and the school said if it weren't for the grant, it wouldn't.

The advice from the Infrastructure Group gave it about 4.5 out of 5 but Treasury "went another way" but refused go into details of the Treasury advice.

Shaw said he spoke to his colleagues about whether it was possible to get the money back but the decision was made that the agreement had been made in good faith.

Shaw said the Greens put together an "exclusions" list for shovel ready projects, like motorways, which Shaw said would lock in a high-carbon future, but it was an oversight to not apply a wider lens to the project.

Co-leader Marama Davidson said the Greens would have to continue to fight to make sure they were above the 5% threshold to get back into Parliament after October's general election.

Supporting the school's funding was a mistake, they apologised and are trying to find a solution, she said.

Shaw said this also hasn't worked out well for the school. "Their reputation has taken a battering."

The money for the school came from a $3 billion Government fund to provide money for "shovel ready" projects.

The funding was provided on the basis it was an infrastructure project.

Shaw signed off the funding - this is despite the fact that the Greens have a policy stating that the Government should not give money to private schools.

Green Party members have been highly critical of this decision and Shaw has come under intense pressure over the decision.

And it's not just Greens members who are upset.

Yesterday, the Chair of the Taranaki Secondary Schools Principals' Association (TSSPA) Martin Chamberlain published an open letter to Education Minister Chris Hipkins.

"Our members are united in their opposition to the recent 'shovel ready' funding decision in favour of the local Green School," it said.

"We cannot accept taxpayer funding being directed to individuals who will privately own the expanded asset and profit from the venture."

The TSSPA called for a full retraction of any fund or loan offer.

This morning, National leader Judith Collins said if a contract to the school has not been signed, the funding offer needed to be withdrawn.

She was critical of the fact this school was getting Government money, when other schools in the Taranaki region are facing financial difficulty.

 

Comments

The fact that Shaw, an experienced politician and educated man with a Master's degree, approved the grant without first going through this thought process and finding that he should not support it demonstrates again that academic achievement is not evidence of intelligence.