Time to reassess our entire food chains to find better ways

Customers queue outside Countdown central Dunedin last week prior to the lockdown. PHOTO: STEPHEN...
Customers queue outside Countdown central Dunedin last week prior to the lockdown. PHOTO: STEPHEN JAQUIERY
Food supply is in the spotlight and rightly so. Food is a "physiological need" — level one of Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs — above level two, safety and security. The behaviour of supermarket shoppers in a time of crisis demonstrates this at a fundamental level. In our everyday life we take access to food for granted, now we can’t.

Some commentators say it’s too early for food producers in New Zealand, to say, "I told you so".

The commentators are right, we are under lockdown and feeling raw and vulnerable. As a community we have reached out to our health workers and thanked them, the odd scientist is even getting recognised — these are strange times indeed.

For many, it’s time to eat humble pie and thank our farmers as well. Food as the mainstay of our economy (and our own food security) will prevail, as it did in the revival from the global financial crisis. Farmers don’t gloat, it’s not in their nature, they will quietly nod in acknowledgement and get on with things — as they have always done.

This crisis has highlighted weaknesses in our food supply system and the more I read, the more I am convinced that it is the food system which requires the greatest scrutiny, rather than farmers themselves — perhaps we might shift our focus.

Prof Tim Lang, the UK’s leading expert on food policy, has written a book, Feeding Britain, where he states that, "although not officially at war, the UK is, de facto, facing a wartime scale of food challenge."

He goes on to say that consumers in the UK have access to a greater range of ingredients at better prices than at any time in human history, and yet "all of that masks a bitter reality: we have a massively fragile just-in-time supply chain which could easily collapse; a depleted agriculture sector which produces only about 50% of the food we actually eat, leaving us at the mercies of the international markets; and production methods which are damaging to the environment and human health."(https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/mar/22/tim-lang-interview-p...)

Sounds alarming for the UK right? But, we’re OK sheltered on our islands at the bottom of the world — we produce more food than we can eat. Yes, that’s true, but despite having tried many times, I am unable to obtain data on the percentage of food in our supermarkets which we import, which I believe is high. We produce a lot of milk and meat in New Zealand, but comparatively, not much in the way of vegetables, beans or manufactured/processed foods.

Prof Lang goes on to say something very interesting "At the heart of this crisis is a British willingness to let a small number of corporations dominate food retailing: just eight companies control 90% of our food supply." He’s talking about the supermarkets and their buying power over producers.

It is sad — but understandable — that in this lockdown we are unable to buy directly from farmers via farmers markets or vegetable sellers or butcheries. The New Zealand Government is looking into the duopoly that is our supermarket system and how they are behaving during this crisis and it is also something we should be examining outside of the Covid-19 pandemic.

There is a very interesting report published by Coriolis (in late 2019), commissioned by MBIE and NZTE, where they ask the question "Is this the beginning of the end or the end of the beginning? Finding the future of the New Zealand food industry."

The report is worth a read, they examine the intensity of our land-use — remember intensity doesn’t always mean more cows, it may mean more vegetables, more horticulture — asking the question what is the best use of different land types?

The report also asks — are we are missing out on food manufacturing jobs by having our major food companies predominantly selling ingredients to others (offshore).

These are important topics to examine, debate and understand, not just in terms of food value and jobs, but also in the interests of our national food security — our "physiological needs".

New Zealanders culturally cringe at the fact that we are an agricultural nation — this is noticeable by how the media portrays food production, how we educate our children, how saddled our farmers have become with bureaucracy and how our research and development spend has moved away from primary production.

The Covid-19 crisis will be a chance for our country to re-position. How should we use our land? What do we want to grow? How do we want to support our growers? How do we want to manufacture more of what we grow? And how should we sell what we grow? This is a collaborative opportunity for growers, private businesses and government — the cringe should be banished.

To finish — a virtual hug from me to all my readers. Kia kaha.

 - Anna Campbell is managing director of AbacusBio Ltd, a Dunedin based agri-technology company.


In many ways the climate alarmists are getting a partial experience of what they have been pushing for, a rollback of our society to the 1990 or even further.
We can continue for a short while like this without to much personal discomfort but if it was to continue for a year or two we would be back to a 1920's diet of meat, fish and veg. Even much of the wheat that makes our daily bread is imported. Can you imagine bread rationing?
There is no doubt that we are a great farming nation but our diversity in this area is not great.
The greatest food exporting nation is the USA but how many know who is number two. Here are a few clues. It is the size of Canterbury. It has a population of 17 million. Dairy, potatoes and vegetables are it's top producers, many of which are sold as value added products. Here is the big give away, a third of the country is below sea level.
If you want to get an idea of how they do it, check this out.

The fact we have food locked away on shelves, in chillers and freezers in small retailers shops that are unable to open is terrible. All of the food has a life span and much will have to be dumped. It is criminal.
I also noted David Seymours comment at the Epidemic Response committee yesterday, saying how closing smaller local food outlets, forces people to travel further and to more crowded stores, where the chances of cross contamination will be greater.
If Halal butchers can be opened with a captains call, so can mad ones....

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter