Council urged to add fluoride to entire drinking supply

Fluoride should be added to all council-run drinking water supplies in Central Otago for the good health of residents, district councillors were told this week.

Emeritus Prof Peter Herbison, who worked in the University of Otago Health Science Division before retiring to Bannockburn, urged the Central Otago District Council to add fluoride.

Prof Herbison spoke at a hearing of submissions to the council's 10-year-plan on Wednesday.

In the plan, the council said improving water treatment to meet the New Zealand Drinking Water Standards, to deliver safe and wholesome water supplies, was a key issue. It had nine drinking water schemes and all were chlorinated to mitigate the risk of bacterial contamination.

"The water you propose to deliver to homes in the regions will still be making people ill," Prof Herbison said.

There was new evidence fluoride was especially good for the health of children and the elderly, he said.

Cr Martin McPherson said the addition of fluoride was a health issue and the district health board should make the decision rather than leaving it to local authorities.

Prof Herbison said there was no evidence fluoride posed a health risk, and no good reasons not to add it to water supplies.

Cr Victoria Bonham said individuals could make the decision about fluoride themselves and take fluoride tablets if they wanted to.

Prof Herbison said to avoid the problems experienced when the Havelock North drinking water supply was contaminated, it was better to add fluoride to drinking water and people could then use filters to remove it if they wanted.

"Otherwise what happened in Havelock North could happen in lots of places. If you don't have enough fluoridation, the water will still make people ill."

Cr Neil Gillespie thought most people received enough fluoride from toothpaste, but Prof Herbison said the recommended daily intake for good health was double that ingested through toothpaste.

The council also received a written submission from Jean Anderson, who referred to a letter by a group called Physicians and Scientists for Global Responsibility New Zealand.

The group asked councils throughout the country to keep drinking water free of fluoride.

It said the risks of fluoride had been exaggerated, but so had the benefits.

Comments

""The water you propose to deliver to homes in the regions will still be making people ill," Prof Herbison said"
"There was new evidence fluoride was especially good for the health of children and the elderly, he said".
Yet he doesn't provide that evidence.

"Otherwise what happened in Havelock North could happen in lots of places. If you don't have enough fluoridation, the water will still make people ill."
Rubbish. If people want flouride then they can buy it in pill form or toothpaste, I don't want to be mass medicated. Why people insist on putting poison in the water is beyond me.

Here in Canada both Edmonton and Calgary had fluoride in their drinking water, but the city of Calgary discontinued the practice in 2011.
A University of Calgary study has since shown Edmonton children have more cavities. Fluoride is most certainly not necessary for overall health, or even dental health; how many more poisons must be added to drinking water to make it 'safe?'

I don't want fluoride in our water!
If there are people out there that want it, that's their choice but don't force it on those that don't.
If the powers the be would only investigate the affects fluoride has on the body they wouldn't do this.
PLEASE RETHINK THIS MATTER CAREFULLY

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter