Appeal against conviction lost after Invercargill teen's death

An Invercargill man sentenced to life imprisonment over the death of Invercargill teen Jack McAllister has lost an appeal against his conviction.

Justice Gilbert released his decision today following an appeal in the Court of Appeal from Christopher James Brown, who was found guilty as party to the murder of McAllister after a jury trial in 2018.

He was sentenced to life imprisonment and ordered to serve a minimum period of imprisonment of 10 years.

The incident happened on June 8, 2017, when 19-year-old McAllister was lured to Stadium Southland with the promise of sex from a young woman. He was then attacked by a group of seven people, suffering 14 stab wounds, including one which severed a major artery.

The decision states Brown’s lawyer Fiona Guy-Kidd appealed his conviction, arguing that a miscarriage of justice occurred at his trial on three occasions.

She believed illegitimate and prejudicial propensity evidence was given by a family member of Brown about his tendency to “rage”.

The declining of the judge to warn the jury about the reliability of the evidence from a 16-year-old woman who was involved in the incident was also highlighted by Ms Kidd.

She said her client argued the woman had a motive to give false evidence about him because she hoped to get a reduction on her sentence at appeal in recognition of her assistance in giving evidence for the Crown.

The last point of the appeal was a letter from the same woman to Mr Brown from prison - she wrote to him saying she had told lies at the trial.

In his decision, Justice Gilbert states  the comments from the family member were irrelevant and he was not persuaded that there was “any real risk of a miscarriage of justice having occurred on this ground”.

About the lack of warning from the judge, Justice Gilbert states the decision to decline to give a reliability warning about the woman's evidence was adequate and he did not consider there was any real risk the outcome of the trial was affected.

Justice Gilbert also dismissed the appeal about the letter, saying the woman confirmed the contents of her affidavit at the hearing of the appeal and was cross-examined on it.

"We accept her explanation for making the statements in her letter to Mr Brown — she felt responsible for the events that unfolded and wished to assist Mr Brown with his conviction appeal."

Brown and six other people were charged in relation to the murder of Mr McAllister. Brayden Whiting-Roff pleaded guilty to murder shortly before the trial and was sentenced to life imprisonment and ordered to serve a minimum period of 12 years and six months.

The 16-year-old woman pleaded guilty to being a party to Mr McAllister's murder four months prior to the trial and agreed to give evidence for the Crown. She was sentenced to life imprisonment and ordered to serve a minimum period of 10 years.

Laura Scheepers was sentenced to 12 months' home detention after being found guilty of manslaughter. The remaining three defendants were found not guilty during the trial.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter