Home ownership a fading dream in Dunedin

Dunedin man Joseph Potter has had eight offers on homes rejected and now he is not sure if he...
Dunedin man Joseph Potter has had eight offers on homes rejected and now he is not sure if he will ever get a house. PHOTO: GERARD O’BRIEN
Home ownership is fast becoming one of the most controversial small talk topics. Otago’s median house price has ballooned over the past couple of years, so is owning a home still a possibility? Business reporter Riley Kennedy talks to two people on either side of Otago’s property market.

"The number of houses sold for more than $3 million in the Queenstown Lakes area has gone through the roof."

"Dunedin has bucked the nationwide trend for the number of properties listed for sale last month, CoreLogic says."

"Central Otago and Queenstown Lakes have overtaken Auckland as the most expensive region to buy property, new industry data shows."

Those were among stories about property appearing in the Otago Daily Times over the past month.

Traditionally, home ownership is something many younger people try to achieve but as more and more headlines point to prices rising and stocks dropping, are the hopes of being a homeowner are diminishing?

Joseph Potter believed they were.

The 43-year-old public servant from Dunedin had eight offers declined over a four-month period last year — a process that left him feeling "bloody exhausted".

"It feels like being rejected. I know it shouldn’t, but it does. But all it is ... someone has just put more money than you.

"It is just stressful," he said.

Mr Potter believed having an offer declined took an emotional toll on someone as well.

"It is like when you put in a job application or when you ask someone to go out with you. The whole point is that you are waiting for that thing you want to happen to happen, and then you get that phone call, it is like a psychological punch," he said.

Previously, homeowners would have been able to get a builder’s report done on the property before making an offer but Mr Potter said the sheer number of people showing interest in a home when it was on the market did not make that possible anymore.

"You have to go in committing to all or nothing, hell or high water.

"As a potential homeowner nowadays, you can’t rely on those safety nets. You are either in or out," he said.

For three of his offers on homes, Mr Potter, "a bit naively" put in a clause that meant the sale would be subject to due diligence.

"I found out after that it pretty much poisoned those offers," he said.

Mr Potter was seeking his own place — "just something for me".

"Ideally, a two-bedroom home, something comfortable, a bit of a section and I may have been asking a lot. I did wonder that.

"I just wanted my own spot, my own digs," he said.

Originally, his bank approved a mortgage on a home worth $400,000, but it quickly became apparent that it was not going to be enough in the Dunedin market.

One house Mr Potter had his eye on, in Roebuck Rise, Broad Bay, was valued at $440,000, over his mortgage limit.

Mr Potter spoke to the bank and got his mortgage bumped up to $440,000 and made the offer.

"It was a great house, views of the harbour, just beautiful, plenty of open space but it went for $480,000.

"I was gutted," he said.

Mr Potter was using the Government’s first-home buyers grant which is capped at houses valued at $425,000 in Dunedin.

The scheme gives first-home buyers, or a previous home owner who had been making regular KiwiSaver contribution for between three and five years, a grant for their home of up to $10,000, depending on income.

Dunedin’s median house price was over $600,000 and that made it difficult for Mr Potter to use the grant on Dunedin homes.

Putting together the first offer was "terrifying," Mr Potter said.

"Signing yourself up for $400,000 worth of debt and you have no idea what is going to happen," he said.

Just before Christmas last year, Mr Potter made his eighth offer on a home, which again was rejected.

"I just lost it, I couldn’t do anything more," he said.

Mr Potter thought over the four-month period, he probably went to over 30 open homes.

"Once I had an offer rejected, I was straight back into looking for open homes.

"The hardest part was trying to map them all out to get to as many as I could when they were all open," he said.

Mr Potter would see the same familiar faces at open homes each time.

"You would follow each other round, help them park, it sort of became a bit of a community.

"An unfortunate community, really," he said, laughing.

Since his last offer was rejected late last year, Mr Potter has not tried again.

Signing up to a new rental agreement and issues with South Dunedin’s insurance on flood-prone areas have put him off trying again for the time being.

In December last year, Deep South Challenge published a report that said thousands of Dunedin homes could face soaring insurance premiums — or even have cover pulled altogether — within 15 years.

In Dunedin, premiums on 3100 such properties could leap from $1600 to $7600 and $7900, with 13cm and 14cm of sea-level rise respectively.

"That, along with the ever-increasing, median house price and the no movement on the first-home owners grant, I can’t see myself getting in any time soon," Mr Potter said.

Predictions of rising interest rates on mortgages was also a factor, he said.

Buying a house with a friend was also an option but something Mr Potter did not really want to have to do.

"It is not because I don’t want to do it with them, it is a big thing to put on a friendship.

"Signing up to a 20-year mortgage with someone and if something went wrong, it is just a bit of a risk.

"My family have been great support as well," he said.

On the other side of the property market, John Dow has completed the housing cycle.

He began investing in property in Dunedin in the 1980s, buying student flats in North Dunedin.

Mr Dow started off with two two-bedroom flats, but a wall went up in both to make them three bedrooms.

Back then, there was a "claw-back tax" which meant home owners had to own their properties for more than 10 years to avoid paying tax on them.

In 1993, Mr Dow and his wife, Christine, sold his North Dunedin properties and moved to Wanaka.

"After New Zealand Valuation sold out to Quotable Value (QV) value, we thought there wasn’t anything here for us now," he said.

A sharemarket crash at the same time meant properties and sections were going cheaper than usual.

When the couple moved to Wanaka, they bought one home but quickly scaled up to five.

Mortgages were secured privately but they had 1% extra in interest.

"We decided to keep right out of the bank. We did not want to do it that way," he said.

They owned the houses for more than 20 years until they were debt-free.

Being a landlord was a tough game, Mr Dow said.

"Boy, can I tell you some stories.

"We only ever had one tenant lose his four weeks bond and he was a business owner in Wanaka," he said.

There was never any shortage of demand for rentals, as skifields kept the town going in the winter and people looking for a summer getaway.

"We had all sorts, helicopter pilots, tourists, skiers. By and large, everyone respected our properties but there were some that were ruined.

"We had some good tenants but we had some terrible ones as well," he said.

On one occasion, Mr Dow was called by a tenant to tell him there had been a fire in the house.

A rack in front of a log fire had caught fire, which jumped over to the curtain.

"We did an insurance job for that but that was the worst incident," he said.

Mr Dow saw a noticeable change in property prices in Wanaka over that time.

"Oh heck, yes, unbelievable.

"Our house here in Mosgiel is only worth what our section is worth in Wanaka," he said.

The couple sold their properties in Wanaka five years ago and moved to Mosgiel but still have one home in Wanaka as a holiday home.

Wanaka had changed "massively" over theplast 20 years and not for the better. Mr Dow described it as a "flashy hallow".

"People said it wasn’t going to be another Queenstown but it is starting to be," he said.

He would not get back into property investing after the Government’s legislation change early this year to extend the bright-line test.

"You are not in control of your own destiny anymore, especially with this Labour Government, you’d be crazy to own a house now.

"I’m glad we got out when we did."




View all

The myth of the "invisible hand of the market" is fully exposed now, after 30+ years of Roger Douglas' experiment.
Houses. Electricity. Telecommunications. Supermarkets......etc.
There is no such thing as the "freemarket" supposedly making things fair for us all.

There is only, just as there has ever been, the few getting richer at the expense of the many. They control the "market". Same as it ever was.

Q: Will we ever a red or blue government intervene in these situations?
A: Probably not - they are too beholden to those who are profiting from this situation. Depressing, innit?

I agree 100 % with Tangent,Rogernomics is the cause of it all.The other aspect was the change in immigration policy which moved from skills based to buying your way in.Too much money chasing too few goods = inflation.On You Tube,Jim Bolger,Prime Minister after Douglas & co states that he does not like the way NZ has evolved & that the trickle down effect has not happened.

The only real winners here are the (aussie owned) banks, making record profits, and real estate agents, who still charge the same commission as 10 years ago, actively giving them massive pay rises for half the effort. I recall back in the 70's and 80's plane loads of kiwis flying to Oz by the day to find work. Will we see this again for affordable regional* housing across the ditch?

Several factors for the current housing crisis, lack of new home builds as some describe it as urban sprawl, you add the Labour lead current RMA act developers have to fight with. Lack of building supplies. Council red tape and its a money making scheme.

Your viewpoint focuses only on the present.You need to look over at the last 35 years to discover the truth.

Reject debt. Go small. Setup your children. The boomer curse will soon be wiped from the earth. https://www.boxabl.com/

Ok...even if you own a home here DCC and ORC are doing their best to kill that dream with these outrageous rates increases. If you look at the country as a whole, rates have gone up. The difference is we get bubbles and bike lanes while the rest of the country gets infastructure. I'm so sorry we bought a house in Dunedin, DCC and ORC will bleed us dry with nothing to show.

Again just goes to show you never truly own property..... stop paying the rates bill and see what happens......

View all