Comment permalink

Winston Peters and Jacinda Ardern. Photo: RNZ
Winston Peters and Jacinda Ardern. Photo: RNZ
NZ First leader Winston Peters has completely broken ranks from the Coalition government, saying he'd pushed for the army to be called in, masks to be worn and independent oversight of the Covid response, two days before New Zealand's first lockdown in March.

He told Newstalk ZB's Mike Hosking this morning that he regretted "in a way" not speaking out publicly at the time, but said he was bound by ensuring the Cabinet worked as a team with a cohesive approach - and that systems mattered.

Peters was responding to what he described as a "cheap shot" , after Hosking yesterday suggested Peters was gilding the lily in not taking responsibility for some of the holes in New Zealand's Covid response. "It's a cheap shot, you're wrong."

He said he had urged the Cabinet, two days before the first lockdown, that the military needed to be called in, that masks needed to be used, and that independent overseers such as Heather Simpson should be hired.

"The problem was we were trusting a bureaucracy and frankly I never would. In this business you ensure you have oversight, constant referral back every week - what's going wrong, what's going right."

Asked why he didn't speak publicly at the time, he said if you wanted to win an argument in an organisation, you work with people behind closed doors. But there was no harm in outlining the facts respectively - and no one in the Cabinet, including the Prime Minister, could deny that he'd been pushing the case for the military and masks.

"We're five months too late doing most of these things but we are doing them now. We finally got the army in, we finally got masks in."

He had a final swipe at Hosking: "Your team, Mike, the National party and Act party, haven't got a hope in China of making it. You know that. You better be counting on commonsense and rationality, you better be backing a party called NZ First."

The Government meets today to decide the immediate future of New Zealand's alert level 2 status - and a health expert believes stricter rules around masks in Auckland will help speed up a lowering to level 1.

Health officials are confident they are on top of the community outbreak of Covid-19 cases, ahead of the Cabinet meeting today to assess alert level settings - but warn cases will likely continue for several more weeks.

There were two new Covid-19 cases announced yesterday - one case a 21-year-old man linked to the Americold cool store group of cases and who was already in isolation as a close contact, and another woman in managed isolation.

The current alert level settings (level '2.5' for Auckland and 2 for the rest of the country) are in place until Sunday, September 6 - but Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern is set to announce a decision today on whether the country stays with that status for longer.

Prof Nick Wilson. Photo: supplied
Prof Nick Wilson. Photo: supplied
Otago University Professor of Public Health Nick Wilson told Newstalk ZB today that he did not expect Cabinet would lower the alert level to 1 from Sunday - but he did not think it would be too far off, especially if masks were used more frequently.

"We are not really seeing enough evidence yet of really good control ... we still get cases every day in the community. To be really confident, we should be waiting to see days where there's no new cases," Wilson told Mike Hosking.

"I think we could move faster [by] using masks better."

He believed masks could be made mandatory in areas other than public transport, which would help speed up elimination of the virus and a return to level 1.

That would be good for business, too, he said, in that with more mask-wearing, physical distancing could be reduced.

Dr William Rainger, director of Auckland Regional Public Health Service, joined Health Minister Chris Hipkins at Middlemore Hospital for yesterday's cases update, and told media "we can be pretty confident that we are on top of this".

"The epidemic curve peaked about two weeks ago, it is undulating downwards. We have had the Mt Roskill church congregation, which has given it a little spike, but the direction of travel is downwards," Rainger said.

"So all the current clusters that we are aware of and working on, we believe we have well contained ... but we would expect to see cases for probably another few weeks."

An "overwhelming" majority of cases were already identified through contact tracing and tested as a result of that, Rainger said.

Asked about one recent case without a confirmed link - a person whose brother travelled to Hobbiton - he said it was under investigation but "is likely to have been a historical exposure".

"There has been no onward spread as a result of that. That makes us believe that there is no further risk associated with those cases."

Comments

View all

This from the man who wanted a trans-Tasman bubble without delay.

Damn. I hope he is lying, otherwise I might just have to vote for him - despite all his other faults.

Oh Winston never lies, he's been around too long and is too canny for that. But on the other hand you can never be sure that what he says is the complete, unbridled truth. When deciding on whether you will vote for NZ First you need to consider more than Winston Peters. At his age this is likely to be his last term. Look at who he has lined up to replace him as leader? The cuddly Shane Jones!? You can expect his influence to expand as Winston starts stepping away. You need to think what you really want in the longer term, Winston is a spent force.

Ah Winny, the polls are not kind to you, so you need a change of direction. Turning on the party that made you deputy PM (and all the power and perks that comes with the job) shows you up for the type of person you are. But then, most of us already knew that.

Don't try and claim the high moral ground - you need to have morals for that.

Election day can't come soon enough to see your sorry carcass gone (for good this time).

Turning on the Party that made him Deputy PM??, he is the one who made them the government

Fairly short memory 'Dunners'. It was actually Winston that made Jacinda the PM not the other way round. Without Winston there was no Labour coalition, a significant reason, I would suggest, why NZF is now polling so low as those right leaning supporters, who previously voted for NZF taking Winston at his word that he would always form a coalition with the largest single party, felt totally blindsided by his move last election and so now will never vote for him again.

Masks, always masks.. If you're not coughing or sneezing, and not running a temperature, you're not sick, so why would you wear a mask? You can't pass on to others what you haven't got.
The only thing left is the virus, and if you think these useless masks could keep the virus out, you're not rowing with both oars in the water.

There is evidence that an asymptomatic person caries as much viral load as a symptomatic person. If you are asymptomatic, you do not know if you have the virus, so you can still spread it. How do you know unless you are tested.

Winston is desperately search for relevance which isn't easy. Labour has done so well all the other parties seem rather pointless now.
The main concern is that Jacinda Ardern remains PM, all other options will result in the sort of virus deaths now being seen in Australia and all the other countries run by right wing governments.
These are exceptional times, and even though NZ is doing it tough, when you look at all other comparable countries NZ is way out in front of the race, health wise, and economy wise.

"Devil's Dictionary
Peer Review: The act of banding together a group of like-minded academics with a funding conflict of interest, for the purpose of squeezing out any research voices that threaten the multi-million dollar government grant gravy train.
Settled Science: Betrayal of the scientific method for politics or money or both.
Denier: Anyone who suspects the truth.
Climate Change: What has been happening for billions of years, but should now be flogged to produce 'panic for profit.'
Nobel Peace Prize: Leftist Nutcase Prize, unrelated to "Peace" in any meaningful way.
Data, Evidence: Unnecessary details. If anyone asks for this, see "Denier," above.
Climate Scientist: A person skilled in spouting obscure, scientific-sounding jargon that has the effect of deflecting requests for "Data" by "Deniers." Also skilled at affecting an aura of "Smartest Person in the Room" to buffalo gullible legislators and journalists. "
-David, Lancaster, PA, 15 February, 2010

Now add this virus nonsense to the list.

Reading some of these comments is like watching evolution shift into reverse gear.

View all