Comment permalink

Invercargill National MP Penny Simmonds speaks on the Water Services Bill in Parliament on...
Invercargill National MP Penny Simmonds speaks on the Water Services Bill in Parliament on Tuesday. PHOTO: PARLIAMENT HOUSE
For many MPs, Tuesday was their first time back at Parliament for several weeks.

One who did not let any time go to waste upon her return was Invercargill National MP Penny Simmonds, who reeled off several speeches and issued a prominent press release in just a couple of days.

There were some party management reasons for Ms Simmonds stepping up to the plate — most Auckland MPs are still encased in their bubbles and as the House was working to a more or less regular legislative schedule this week that meant someone had to fill National’s speaking slots.

That said, the party was not going to put just anybody up to fill in a few minutes, and Ms Simmonds’ five speeches on Tuesday and Wednesday increased her contributions to the House this Parliament by 21% and demonstrated rising faith in National’s upper echelon that the novice Invercargill MP is starting to find her feet in this new role.

There was little doubt about Ms Simmonds’ likely aptitude for Parliament, given her previous high-profile and highly-regarded role as chief executive of the Southern Institute of Technology.

That said, being an MP is a job like few others and more than a few high-flyers have had their wings clipped in the unique workplace which is the House of Representatives.

Ms Simmonds did have a couple of very minor speed wobbles this week, such as being pulled up for using the word ‘‘you’’ too often — in parliamentary debates that word is taken to be a reference to the Speaker — and being cut short by Waitaki MP and assistant Speaker Jacqui Dean when in full-flow speaking on the Human Rights (Disability Assist Dogs Non-Discrimination) Amendment Bill’s first reading, having mistakenly believed she had a 10-minute call rather than the allotted 5 minutes.

That did mean some germane material was left on the cutting room floor, but Ms Simmonds will no doubt get to recycle it as the Bill winds its way through the process, as she is a passionate and committed spokeswoman on disability issues.

Notable in all her contributions this week was a level of forethought and preparation.

When speaking on the Water Services Bill, she referenced a fact-finding tour of water schemes in Central Otago, and she also localised the issue when speaking on Land Transport (Clean Vehicles) Amendment Bill.

‘‘The geography of Southland is the same size as the country of Switzerland. You cannot get around Southland easily in an EV.’’

Ms Simmonds was back again on Thursday morning advocating for the South — this time the entire island, not just her own Switzerland-sized piece of it.

All National’s nine South Island MPs signed a letter addressed to Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern which asked why the South, which has been Covid-19 free for almost a year, could not revert to Alert Level 1.

The letter was not likely to get the desired response — on Monday the prime minister deferred reassessment of the alert levels for a fortnight, barring another outbreak somewhere.

What it was intended to do, though, was to highlight the issues faced by southern businesses due to Covid-19 lockdowns — there have been 15,000 wage subsidy claims in Southland and several business closures — and position National as having those people’s backs.

Labour, of course, would argue that the wage subsidy demonstrates exactly the same thing, but National hardly cares about that.

‘‘People want to know why the South Island continues to be restrained in this way, and that’s why my colleagues and I have asked the Prime Minister to release the rationale behind her decision,’’ Ms Simmonds said.

Liz Craig
Liz Craig
The Prime Minister declined to do so, but getting that information was not really the point; getting the names of National’s local MPs in the limelight was, and on that score Ms Simmonds can account herself as having had a reasonably successful week.

Lest we forget

Last Sunday was Suffrage Day, a time for reflection on the passage of the Electoral Act of 1893, which gave New Zealand women the right to vote.

For Invercargill Labour list MP Dr Liz Craig the day is personal; her great grandmother, Rachael Marsden, signed the original suffrage petition in Dunedin.

Gone but not forgotten, 1

No sooner announced than axed, the Dorothy Fraser lecture highlighted last week became a Covid-19 casualty this week.

Taieri Labour MP Ingrid Leary promises it will be rescheduled.

Gone but not forgotten, 2

A fixture of the Order Paper for most of this year has been a motion, usually moved by National’s Chris Bishop but occasionally by his colleague Dunedin list MP Michael Woodhouse, that the House has no confidence in Speaker Trevor Mallard.

Joseph Mooney
Joseph Mooney
Unsurprisingly, the Government has not felt the need to debate this, not that that stopped National from asking.

In recent weeks the no confidence motion has quietly been dropped, but National insists its issues with Mr Mallard have not gone away so, it would not be a surprise if something similar reappeared in the coming weeks.

Luck of the draw

It has been a sparse time of it in the member’s Bill lottery for southern MPs, but Southland MP Joseph Mooney turned that all around on Thursday when his Te Ture Whenua Maori Bill, all 396 pages of it, was drawn from Parliament’s famous biscuit tin.


Poor Nats, I'm glad someone from the ODT felt sorry for them and given them some feel good publicity. I guess Mike making Penny seem like a top MP will take the facts off I watch parliament TV regularly and rate Penny a poor performer - mainly the result of lousy mentors on her side.
In the meantime what you missed Mike is again the other day Jacinda spat out Collins, Bishop & Seymour one after the other having each of them foundering for another relevant question that wasn't a repeat of the last question where Jacinda had to constantly say "if the member listened to my previous answer"..
BTW regards Mallard - he would have to be the most fair & neutral speaker I've ever known.
When you get spare time Mike, do an article on what Collins would have done if she was PM. (sits back with popcorn ...)

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter