You Exist Too Much

YOU EXIST TOO MUCH
Zaina Arafat
Hachette

REVIEWED BY PETER STUPPLES

The narrator of Zaina Arafat’s novel relates the story of her ‘coming of age’ from the vantage of the present, when she is a middle-aged woman at last leading a settled life with her partner, Anouk, in New York. She was born in Neblus, Palestine to a beautiful, well-educated mother from a distinguished family and cardiac-surgeon father.

Due to the constant violence between the government of Israel and the Palestinians, her parents emigrated to Washington DC in the United States when the narrator - never named - is 4. Her parents, like her grandparents, were always quarrelling and separated when she was a young teenager.

The narrator then lives with her mother in the US, visiting relatives in Palestine, Jordan and Lebanon every year, always conscious of having two homes, two languages, and two cultures, yet never comfortably committed to either.

As a teenager, the narrator, early and vigorously, participates in sexual activity with both boys/men, but especially girls/women. She knows no boundaries. When she tells her mother that she prefers women to men her mother throws her out of the house, as she will bring shame to her Arabic family. This only accelerates the narrator’s promiscuity, her drinking and clubbing playing havoc with her college education and graduate school programme.

The novel, which has no plot other than the combative, and often infuriating, narrator’s long struggle to find peace within herself, to find an equilibrium in her otherwise chaotic social life, describes the lives of a wide range of people she meets along the way.

They are all struggling to find meaning for themselves in our world, where cultural values have been discarded and nothing of substance has taken their place.

The core of the book relates her experience of a 28-day programme in a group therapy centre where her acute intelligence finds many of the activities wanting, despite the good intentions of a caring staff. When she leaves, she soon reverts to her previous self-destructive behaviour, though she has been strengthened to cope, and an increasing maturity enables her to look for more stable solutions.

Arafat has written a thought-provoking study of cultural dislocation and the problems western freedoms bring in their wake when traditional values are abandoned. Rather unfortunately, it seems, freedom without responsibility comes at a high price.

Peter Stupples, now living in Wellington, used to teach at the University of Otago

Add a Comment

Local journalism matters - now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic brings the world into uncharted waters, Otago Daily Times reporters and photographers continue to bring you the stories that matter. For more than 158 years our journalists have provided readers with local news you can trust. This is more important now than ever.

As advertising drops off during the pandemic, support from our readers is crucial. You can help us continue to bring you news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter