Baxter Memorial close to going ahead on new site

The proposed site of the Archibald Baxter Memorial for World War 1 conscientious objectors, at...
The proposed site of the Archibald Baxter Memorial for World War 1 conscientious objectors, at the garden plot at the intersection of George and Albany Sts. Photos: ODT.
With a new site and a new  design, the Archibald Baxter Memorial for World War 1 conscientious objectors is back on track.

Archibald Baxter.
Archibald Baxter.
Earlier this year, as the Archibald Baxter Memorial Trust was preparing to announce the winning memorial design, to be built in the Otago Museum Reserve, it was discovered a major partner in the project had partially withdrawn its support for the project.

Archibald Baxter Memorial Trust chairman and University of Otago National Centre for Peace and Conflict Studies director Prof Kevin Clements said  after it became clear the trust had no realistic chance of retaining the Museum Reserve site for the memorial, the Dunedin City Council offered a smaller but more prominent site at the intersection  of George and Albany Sts.

The Archibald Baxter Memorial aimed to honour Mr Baxter and his companions in a reflective sculptural setting, offering visitors a chance to contemplate their sacrifice and consider alternatives to war.

"Unlike the Museum Reserve, this is not a place for quiet contemplation, but it is passed by large numbers of pedestrians and vehicles every day.

"This seems appropriate insofar as Baxter himself took his stand against the madness of war amid the noise and tumult of the front line in France and Belgium.

The proposed site of the Archibald Baxter Memorial for World War 1 conscientious objectors, at...
The proposed site of the Archibald Baxter Memorial for World War 1 conscientious objectors, at the garden plot at the intersection of George and Albany Sts.
"We are happy with this site because it will attract many visitors and provide a talking point which other more spacious but remote sites would not."

Kevin Clements.
Kevin Clements.
Prof Clements said the memorial was being designed by Shane Woolridge, of Arrowtown, and Paddy Baxter, of Queenstown, and plans were expected to be complete by the end of this month.

At this stage, the memorial was expected to be made of stone, resembling three figures tied to posts on the front line, for Field Punishment No1.

It would be surrounded by native alpine plants which were favoured by Mr Baxter’s wife, Millicent.

It was hoped construction of the memorial would be complete by the end of next year.

"We just need to get final approvals and then we’re ready to go."

Prof Clements said the site presented some practical challenges, notably the presence of buried service pipes, so any structure would need to be removable to allow maintenance work.

"We are working closely with the council to ensure all such technical requirements will be met."

Comments

Baxter's struggle was against the concept of war - why is this monument going to represent "Number 1 Field Punishment", the heinous punishment meted out to him and his fellow objectors on behalf of the NZ government? Why not a monument to the concept of a world without war? A world in which we raise each other up, not strike each other down? or tie people onto poles?
Can some one please explain the design choice? How does it reflect what Baxter was seeking to achieve?
Thank you.

Disgusting! I wonder just how long this monument will stand to remind us of these citizens of NZ! My two Grandfathers and others Grandfathers will be turning in their graves! this monument is nothing but a disgusting insult to our country,our people and Kiwis who fought in the Great Wars !

 

Advertisement