Consent for new hospital risks wasting taxpayer dollar - panel

The latest concept design image for the new Dunedin Hospital buildings, supplied by the...
The latest concept design image for the new Dunedin Hospital buildings, supplied by the Government late last year. IMAGE: SUPPLIED
The Ministry of Health says it will continue seeking fast-track consent for groundworks for the new Dunedin Hospital despite the independent panel assessing the application questioning whether that is wise.

Consents for the $1.47 billion project are being sought in stages and the ministry is at the beginning of stage 1 — applying for fast-track consenting for the foundations and groundworks for the two main hospital buildings and ancillary buildings.

The panel has now questioned the ministry about its planned two-pronged approach of asking for consents for the buildings at a later date.

It also warned changes that might be asked for if consents were later granted for the hospital buildings could mean the ministry had wasted taxpayer money building consented groundworks only to need to change them.

The panel gave the examples of traffic management, urban design, management of wind flow and shadowing as factors which might be questioned when the ministry applied for consents for the buildings.

"Does the applicant accept it might have wasted financial resources in building the stage 1 structures (if consented), only to find some not usable because of changes needed above ground?" the panel asked.

"... Might the applicant prefer to defer consideration of the stage 1 application at this stage, and bring both stages before a panel contemporaneously, perhaps as one single project?"

The Environmental Protection Authority, the body overseeing the application, has just released the correspondence between the independent panel deciding the application and the ministry.

In its reply, the ministry said it accepted it would have been preferable to have lodged a single consent application but design challenges, many caused by the Covid-19 pandemic, meant waiting until all plans were completed would have caused too great a delay.

"The ministry has carefully considered the implications of that delay against the risks of a staged consenting process (including the risks identified by the panel) and has determined that it will take the risk of progressing the consent in stages."

Much of the demolition work on the twin inner city sites the new hospital is intended to be built on has been completed.

The ministry still intends to open the new outpatient building in January 2025 and the larger inpatient building in April 2028.

The ministry said the state of the current hospital, which lacks surgical theatre capacity and has several buildings which are in poor condition or no longer fit for purpose, meant it needed to take urgent action to avoid compromising the health of southerners.

"Moreover, the current market conditions are such that the costs of programme delays are likely to be much more significant than the costs of any redesign work that may arise as a result of misaligned stages.

"The ministry is also mindful that this project — and the large number of jobs it will provide — are a key part of the district’s recovery from the social and economic impacts of Covid-19."

All those factors meant the ministry was committed to starting the new Dunedin Hospital project as quickly as possible and was prepared to accept the risks the panel had identified.

"That risk has been fully traversed and it is accepted that the risk of disconnection between the stages, and the financial and programme costs associated with remedying any such issues, lie with the ministry."

The panel is now awaiting comments on the hospital project from invited parties, and has received seven responses.

The deadline for further responses is Monday.


Honestly !?!?
This kind of BS is what it costing this country its dignity. It's an embarrassment! By the time they get consents through, jump every hurdle put in the way, Dunedin could have had 3 hospitals, twice the size, and a new road system that would work.

"... Might the applicant prefer to defer consideration of the stage 1 application at this stage, and bring both stages before a panel contemporaneously, perhaps as one single project?"


"This is actually one project, please get all relevant documentation required so they can be signed off together."

But no, that's too simple and the people who use all the fancy words don't get paid enough if they use "simple English" ... reason ... Joe & Jane Bloggs would know they're being ripped off, without having to use Google !!

The ineptitude of the people running this project is astounding. Unfortunately they're more concerned about tiny little problems that could be sorted out over a pint at the bar down the pub rather than bars in court costing millions ... not to mention the number of lives lost due to unwanted and unnecessary delays.

You dyed-in-the-wool Labour voters seeing through this sham government and its 1bn+ vote buy?

Do they know what they are doing?

This is all mind-numbing really. At least 2 years of huff and puff, millions splashed around on "experts" and hanger-ons and paper pushers are picking at each other about how to start building something.

This pretty much shows what is wrong with NZ's entire building approval process. Having allowed developers and builders to do whatever they wanted for years resulting in the leaky building mess, we now have multilayered impediments from beginning to end.

No wonder new housing is so expensive and basically unaffordable for young people. A bit of common sense is needed, but that seems to be missing from politicians of all flavours.



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter