‘Put through hell’ by Immigration NZ

Ohau Snow Fields had a record opening day when the season kicked off at the weekend. PHOTO: MIKE NEILSON
Ohau Snow Fields had a record opening day when the season kicked off. PHOTO: MIKE NEILSON
Frustration at trying to secure staff has taken the gloss off a booming return to business for Ohau Snow Fields and Lake Ohau Lodge owner Mike Neilson.

During lockdown the lodge lost “6000 guest nights” over a three-month period. But bookings were filling up quickly as people who had originally planned overseas holidays opted to support local instead, Mr Neilson said. But he and wife Louise were being worked off their feet.

“Louise and myself are about to fall over,” he said.

“We’re very heavily booked.

“Our big struggle is that we’re finding it really hard to find staff.”

Mr Neilson said they had positions available for a chef, one or two housekeepers and a bar person.

He had found people to fill the positions, but they were not New Zealanders and he could not get their visas transferred.

“We advertised in Queenstown and got applications from foreign nationals who are stuck, because of Covid, in Queenstown, and we’re trying to get their immigration visas transferred to us, and they’re [Immigration New Zealand] just being really difficult.

“They’re not giving them. Which is really painful.

“They’re saying we need to find New Zealanders, but we’re not finding New Zealanders. New Zealanders are staying in Queenstown. They’ve got a house and they don’t want to move. Whereas the overseas people are happy to move. That’s why they’re travelling anyway.

“They’re [Immigration NZ] putting us through hell, because we are absolutely understaffed at the moment.

“There was a couple of [New Zealand] guys who applied, and my analysis to Immigration was that they’re not suitable. They’re not housekeepers.

“They’d applied saying they’re happy to do anything, and apply for all these jobs you’ve got’. But they weren’t specifically housekeepers and we didn’t have a job for them.

“Immigration are saying we could’ve employed them, they were New Zealanders.”

Mr Neilson said he was reluctant to employ people who were not suited to the job.

“They’re not going to last. I don’t just want average,” he said.

Immigration NZ Border and Visa Operations general manager Nicola Hogg said Covid-19 had ”significantly impacted New Zealand’s labour and employment market”.

”Under immigration instructions, Immigration NZ needs to be satisfied that, at the time the application is assessed, there are no New Zealanders available to do the work before granting an Essential Skills work visa. This also applies for a variation of conditions to be granted.

”[We] may ask employers to provide further evidence to show that the availability of New Zealanders to undertake the work remains unchanged.

”In terms of visa processing . . . there is also an increase in the time and effort required in processing some visa application types due to additional requests for information or comment being required.”

There was a range of visas that allowed migrants to work in New Zealand, she said.

”Some work visas are employer-assisted, meaning the visa is linked to the role being offered, such as an Essential Skills work visa. Where this is the case, visa holders may be able to apply for a variation of conditions in order to change some of the employment conditions that they are subject to, such as location, and employer. If an individual’s work visa is linked to a specific job, that visa will remain valid for as long as the job is available.”

- Ashley Smyth


View all

Well, where’s the “we are all in this together” ? You won’t be receiving my booking this year. New Zealanders should be employed over foreigners.

"All in this Together!" "Team of 5 million" 1.3 million of those born overseas, 300.000 on different types of work visas. Team of 4.7 million? Team of 3.4 million? Pick one please.

It doesn't matter where someone was born - if they're an NZ citizen or resident then they're a Kiwi.

In any case, being a member of the team of 5 million who helped to stop the spread of COVID-19 doesn't entitle those on work visas to get roles ahead of Kiwis.

Well thats weird. My husband and I have been jobhunting nationally from Twizel for over a month since Hermitage laid us off and this is the 1st I heard about these vacancies. Why is he advertising for staff in Queenstown when there are so many experienced NZ citizen hospitality staff living closer by that have just been laid off?

We have over 500k persons on benefits/subsidy support and yet there are no kiwis to fill 2 housekeeping positions? That says heaps about our generous benefits system that pays more to stay home than to work. Something should change or we will bankrupt ourselves as a country.

There were kiwis available - as stated in the article the employer refused to hire them, despite it being an entry-level position and the applicants being willing to do any kind of work.

'Housekeeper' is an entry-level position that almost anyone could be trained to do in relatively little time. Although perfectly capable Kiwis applied, the employer chose not to hire them, instead preferring foreign migrants. Fortunately Immigration NZ has done their job and refused to grant visas where there are Kiwis available to do the work on offer - great job by them, and horrendous conduct on the part of this business owner.

I will be steering well clear of Lake Ohau Lodge if they're going to systematically exclude New Zealanders just so that their mates from overseas get first dibs.

View all

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter