Comment permalink

Selection processes that determine who gets to walk through the doors of the Otago Medical School...
Otago Medical School. PHOTO: PETER MCINTOSH
A legal challenge to the way students are selected for Otago's medical school will not go ahead.

The University of Otago and the man who sought to challenge aspects of its selection process this year have resolved the matter outside of court.

The university and the man, whose name is suppressed, released a statement this afternoon.

In it, they said the man received no compensation.

The agreement between the parties contains no commitments by the university relating to the outcome of any individual’s application for admission to the medical school or any changes to the process.

It does include, however, a concession that increased clarity and transparency about the process would be desirable.

The university's processes have been under scrutiny this year, as leaders started to discuss whether the system that gives priority to students from minority backgrounds should be adjusted.

Priority is given to students who are selected through preferential pathways - Māori, Pacific, rural, low socio-economic, and refugee - but the scheme has resulted in competition being particularly intense in the general pathway.

Most students selected for second-year medicine in 2020 came through the preferential pathways.

The legal challenge, which was to be heard in the High Court, had been expected to touch on those themes.

In resolving the matter, the university did not appear to concede ground to the applicant.

"The university accepts that the proceedings have highlighted the desirability of increased clarity and transparency in its medical admissions process," the joint statement said.

"The applicant is satisfied that the university will be taking appropriate steps over time towards that outcome.

"The applicant accepts that any review of the admissions process must be carried out in respectful consultation with a range of interested parties, including Māori and Pasifika communities, and recognises that the court proceedings are an unhelpful distraction which will not assist with the thoughtful dialogue required."

The university's Mirror on Society policy aims to generate a health workforce more reflective of New Zealand society's make-up and the university has re-asserted its commitment to that policy.

It is regarded as a cornerstone of admissions to health sciences professional programmes at Otago.

The policy is due to be reviewed next year.

University leaders have not ruled out bringing in changes such as capping the number of students gaining entry through preferential pathways.

The parties involved in the legal challenge suggested in their statement that discussions had been helpful.

"The constructive dialogue with the university has satisfied the applicant that the guidance for the future that a court ruling could provide is not required at this stage."



It is easy to see that this policy will fail due to the competition for those who can only use the general pathway. Those who do then get accepted, will likely not become GPs as they are such gifted individuals their skills should be to go on in a specialisation. Quickly, there will be no new GPs other than foreigners or by the preferential pathways and therefore not reflecting NZ population make-up.



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter