Site complications delay roundabout

Contractors work on the peanut-shaped roundabout at the intersection of Forbury, Bay View and...
Contractors work on the peanut-shaped roundabout at the intersection of Forbury, Bay View and Allandale Rds yesterday. PHOTO: PETER MCINTOSH
Another delay for a roundabout a year in the making is causing further frustration at St Clair, Dunedin, with the total cost of infrastructure work in the area likely to exceed $2 million.

Dunedin City Council staff expect the peanut-shaped roundabout at the intersection of Forbury, Bay View and Allandale Rds to be completed by the end of this month and roads to reopen by July 17.

The previous target for completion of the project was the end of June.

Work to replace ageing water, wastewater and stormwater infrastructure had taken longer than expected, because of difficult ground conditions and the need for more extensive excavations, council transport group manager Jeanine Benson said.

"Bad weather in June also disrupted pavement reconstruction work," Ms Benson said.

Crews doing intersection improvements started work in July last year and were originally due to be finished by Christmas, but the completion date was extended six months when it was found water mains and sewer lines in the area needed upgrading.

Complications at the site stretched the completion date out another month.

The roundabout project — including kerb and channel work, pedestrian crossings and landscaping — had been forecast to cost $1 million.

"We expect the total cost will now be more than $1 million, due to ground conditions, more extensive excavations and weather delays to pavement reconstruction work," Ms Benson said.

The final costs have yet to be confirmed.

Water, wastewater and stormwater work in the area had also cost about $970,000.

Bay View Rd collectables shop owner and florist Rachel Reed said the road had been closed since early January.

The works had caused disruption for a lot of people, including customers and residents, and the delays were frustrating, she said.

"I’d like a discount on my rates," she said.

However, Mrs Reed was looking forward to completion of the roundabout.

The council decided on the unusual shape after 11 crashes at the intersection from 2011 to 2015.

"It will be really good when the roundabout is finished, if it’s well designed and in good working order," Mrs Reed said.

"I’m excited about the peanut. That corner was horrendous."

Four Square St Clair owner Sandra Millar said people’s patience continued to be stretched.

Both women said the contractors were just doing their job, but Mrs Reed wondered if the project ought to have been handled differently, to get through it quicker.

An extensive amount of work was happening in fine weather yesterday.

Contractors have also escorted pedestrians across streets in the area and signage states businesses remain open.

Ms Benson said businesses in the area had been visited, letter drops carried out as contractors were trying to keep business people updated.

"Feedback has been largely positive, although we acknowledge the impact on some businesses, which are facing regrettable but unavoidable disruptions as a result of the work," Ms Benson said.

"We are trying our best to keep these disruptions to a minimum and maintain public access to the businesses."

grant.miller@odt.co.nz

Comments

View all

"when it was found water mains and sewer lines in the area needed upgrading." Yes, I'm sure it was a complete surprise. Or is this just the current go to excuse for poor planning?

Bugger !!

I was so disappointed to hear this news .... now I have to wait before I can comment on one the most costly traffic management failures the DCC have come up with.

Most people did a bit of a double take when the DCC said it was going peanut shaped, well it's now gone pear shaped ... doomed from the conception of the idea, the ratepayers will now probably have to fork out another few million to correct yet another DCC traffic management failure.

I would like to know who is coming up with these designs and what experience they have. If this sort of thing was happening in the private sector, heads would most probably be rolling down Baldwin Street at a great rate !

Isn't it about time the DCC was asked to provide costs of building these "islands & roundabouts" ... AND the costs associated with work that's been required to make them negotiable by traffic, especially emergency vehicles and public transport ?

I know there are elderly, disabled, and disadvantaged people who are extremely worried about being able to pay electricity bills and an increase in rates is just not affordable; maybe it is time for some heads to roll at the DCC.

struggling to see the upgrade?

Now who would have thought that bad weather might occur in Dunedin in June? Obviously not the DCC planning department. And these clowns are going to splash tens - hundreds of millions away in the next few years.
Will anyone be surprised with more headlines similar to this for the upcoming waste:
Unforeseen issues
Cost blowouts
Delays in completion
These are the hallmarks of DCC planners after all.

Rather than peanut shaped, I see more of a dog bone or maybe a dumbbell.

Sadly, Mr Sargent the transport manager has made another howler. Someone in City Hall should check his qualifications.

I guess the only saving grace for the council in this is the fact they didn't complete the original job on time (or after) and then get some contractors to come back a couple of months later to dig it all up, fix the pipes and then put it all back together, followed by some more contractors to come back 6 months later to dig it up and fix the other issues. Maybe they have learnt some lessons over the years...Now they just need to learn to hire competent people and Dunedinites need to learn to stop voting in muppets at election time.

...and then they'll be back 3 months later to dig it all up and shrink the 'peanut' down for a obligatory 2mtr wide cycle lane.....and then they'll be back to dig up and shrink the 'peanut' further because buses and fire appliances can't make the turn.....then they'll find a mains water leak, and a footpath upgrade will be required because residents have to many types of refuse and recycling bins......And all this won't cost peanuts! Then they'll scrap the peanut completely and put in traffic lights!!!!!! (puts crystal ball back on the shelf)
Only in Dunedin will you find the steepest street and the most expensive peanut!

Well hopefully that's all it will cost.....peanuts ...... oh wait.......

View all

 

Advertisement