‘Emergency’ must be treated as such

George St businesses have every right to be wary of a plan to all-but pedestrianise Dunedin’s main street at a time when certainty is hard to come by.

Many spent lockdown counting the cost to their businesses and planning to set things right. They accounted for what they knew — that Covid-19 Alert Level 2 restrictions would restrict how they trade — and for the high chance their market will be smaller and more cautious for some time to come.

They had to plan for change forced by the national response to the global pandemic. They must now plan for the still-uncertain effects of a hurriedly-devised response of the city’s own making.

Many are understandably angry the council yesterday decided to drop the speed limit along George St’s retail trade district to 10kmh, to allow pedestrians to mingle more safely with traffic.

The plan was adopted as a means to support retail and hospitality businesses, an option to encourage people to return to the city centre while adhering to the Covid-19 response rules.

Councillors learned physical distancing is a challenge in a space serviced by narrow two-way footpaths. Cafes might also struggle to operate the tables needed to get their businesses running profitably.

The council had the means to minimise the impact of the Covid-19 controls: it could allow business use of the footpaths and could regulate the use of the road to keep pedestrians safe.

An epidemic is considered an emergency when it comes to installing new, temporary speed limits. Thus, the speed limit could be changed as an emergency measure, for no more than 12 months.

The words ‘‘temporary’’ and ‘‘emergency’’ featured prominently in council staff advice and in the debate after which the measures were passed. It was a singular move to help protect people’s lives during a public health crisis — but it was a singular move inevitably coloured by recent temporary tinkering and by many years of debate as to how or if to revitalise and especially, pedestrianise, George St.

A current, preliminary, plan to make the street between Moray Pl and Frederick St one-way is hotly contested. Petitioners oppose it; businesses assert their position as key stakeholders who must be consulted, or be in the tent, if a new-look CBD is planned. They have demonstrated a strong desire to be part of the process for many years, and they have been very firm in their response to measures they considered unnecessary for the street.

With this in mind, it is little wonder many are worse than disappointed by the council’s hurried 10kmh response. No matter the circumstances, it is a decision made without consulting the people most affected by the changes, and by the effects of the pandemic response.

Mayor Aaron Hawkins acknowledged engagement would be better in an ideal world but that during a pandemic, this was not an ideal world.

Health and safety dictated a speedy move. As businesses adjust to a new compliance environment, the city environment will change to help ensure this normal does not endanger lives. Free parking will encourage people into town, though this will be reviewed monthly. The speed and footpath provisions will remain for at least as long as physical distancing is required.

They are temporary and easily reversible, but it would be naive to think they will not influence the council’s longer-term push to make the central city "people friendly".

Traffic calming would be a key component of any such plan, and the council will now have a new opportunity to measure the impact of low-to-no traffic volumes on the street’s use — albeit a street now empty of tourists and crowds. It should also understand how the changes affect the businesses that rely upon a safe and functional George St, even if these times are far from normal.

Then, it must reinstate the speed limit as swiftly as it was changed, ahead of the much more important conversations — and formal consultation — it must have with the community it serves as it maps the future for George St.


View all

State Theatre, 1990.

ODT. Not Possible To Save Historic Building.

The Sun. Council Vandals Destroy Heritage!

Giveaway. Not The New Edinburgh Way Way.

Hull...surely you work at DCC? A policy advisor maybe? Your musings are in sync with their logic and intellect. Explains a lot about the state of the city don't you think? As Ceaser once said "bliteus belua es!" Cheers.

Kaiser. WW, they don't have Jokers at DCC. I am ex PSA, who jumped a freight train South.

Bell Hull.

"They are temporary and easily reversible, but it would be naive to think they will not influence the council’s longer-term push to make the central city "people friendly"."

In other words, we are going to take this opportunity, regardless of the fact that CBD business are on their knees, to experiment with our pet project. It's only going to cost us a few thousand and they can't do anything about it. If they go broke, what does it matter. We can blame it on the virus and maintain our virtue as protectors of 'the people'. A narcissistic narrative to the end.

Choking George st traffic means choking trade. At a time when the news is dominated by job losses? Dunedin’s few streets need to flow and let people come and go. Forcing an idealistic vision upon Dunedin whilst the nation was illegally imprisoned is immoral.

Rather than moaning these businesses could help themselves by providing an alternative. We know the CBD is not friendly to people with high pedestrian injuries and not suited to a future which requires lower environmental footprints. A plan that includes the wider city (stopping and reducing big box retailing on Crawford St and the creep of retail and hospitality toward low value land accessible only by car) is needed. A petition for the status quo is of no help whatsoever.

The mere fact Dunedin businesses weren't consulted as to the changes, is evidence of a "We know best" mentality by the Dunedin City Council.

The end result will be further closures of shops, less pedestrian traffic and yet more decline of our 'main street'

If the ultimate aim of this council is to turn George Street into one long green park, with cycleways and picnic spots, they are on the right track!

View all






Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter