‘All sorts of barriers’ for candidates: councillors

Deputy Mayor Keith Hovell. File photo: Sandy Eggleston
Deputy Mayor Keith Hovell. File photo: Sandy Eggleston
Departing Gore district councillors are questioning whether running for local government is worth the hassle.

Nominations for the council and community board closed last Friday and the council will only be contested in two wards with more seats than candidates in the Mataura Community Board.

Those moving on say there are too many barriers for potential candidates, the system does not suit candidates and stress levels are unacceptable.

Deputy mayor Keith Hovell, Glenys Dickson, Richard McPhail and Bronwyn Reid stepped away and declined to run again, with a variety of reasons given.

Mrs Reid, who served on the council for three terms including a stint as deputy mayor in her second term, said people who she thought would be good candidates had said no.

Glenys Dickson. Photo: supplied
Glenys Dickson. Photo: supplied
"There’s all sorts of barriers for some people. A big wake-up call for people is the time commitment, the reading, you might even be able to read but can you comprehend it?

"I know one or two good [potential] candidates who have said ‘no, the reading would just turn me off’," she said.

Another aspect was the continued access and criticism of councillors, with Mrs Reid pointing out examples where individuals have taken it a step too far.

"The criticism is something too. I probably don’t have a thick enough skin any more. There’s a sort of casual disrespect.

"Are we easy targets? Are we the low-hanging fruit?" she said.

Mr McPhail echoed these sentiments, and said as the job was getting harder, so too was it hard to convince some to sacrifice for the position.

Richard McPhail. Photo: supplied
Richard McPhail. Photo: supplied
"A lot of younger people, who have these skill bases who could make an incredible contribution, they can’t [give the right commitment].

"I don’t think the system caters for the right candidates sometimes," he said.

The other side of it was the stress put on to councillors, which Mr McPhail said he saw firsthand during his two terms.

"I was worried about some of the councillors’ stress during [2022]. I thought the stress the community was putting on them was inappropriate," he said.

"They didn’t sign up for it, they probably didn’t deserve it either. I was concerned about the toll it was taking on members, and the council staff, it wasn’t fair on them either."

The council had been outspoken recently about certain members of the community, calling out relentless criticism and harassment on social media.

Bronwyn Reid. Photo: supplied
Bronwyn Reid. Photo: supplied
Cr Andy Fraser, who is seeking a second term, called out the Gore Rates Reform Group for being wilfully ignorant and disruptive in the community.

Notably two candidates with strong ties to the group, Gary McIntyre and Donna Bruce, are running for seats in the upcoming election.

Deputy mayor Keith Hovell, speaking to The Ensign earlier in the year, also decried disruptive and nasty rhetoric from the community to councillors.

Four nominations have been received for five spots for the Mataura Community Board, however if Steven "Boko" Dixon, who is also running for council, gets on the council, he will have to give up his spot on the board.

A by-election will have to be undertaken to fill the vacancies, with one confirmed and a second potential empty seat on the board.

gerrit.doppenberg@alliedmedia.co.nz