South Africa’s tactical high kicking doing game no favours

Beauden Barrett delivers an offload during the All Blacks win over South Africa on Saturday....
Beauden Barrett delivers an offload during the All Blacks win over South Africa on Saturday. Photo: Reuters
Time to assemble the bomb squad — the next generation.

Operation Save World Rugby.

For the sake of the game, the tactics this Springbok team is employing cannot be successful.

No clue, no endeavour to use the ball on attack. Just bomb, after bomb, after bomb.

During Saturday’s 19-17 loss to the All Blacks, they passed the ball just 66 times in the entire game, and put up 38 kicks.

That is not even two passes for every kick.

Midfielders Damian de Allende and Lukhanyo Am passed the ball once each — that is not a typo.

In contrast, the All Blacks had 142 passes to their 18 kicks.

It is a tactic typical of the Springboks and British teams, but it has never been this bad.

Seeing Faf de Klerk hoist a high box kick while approaching the All Blacks’ 22 was simply ridiculous.

The All Blacks dealt with it well enough to win, but not well enough to make an attractive game.

A rugby purist will call it tough, attritional and ugly.

The masses — and there must be a growing number of purists joining this group — will call it negative, incompetent and boring.

A young New Zealander is not going to watch that game and be inspired to watch again or put on their boots and play.

A potential fan from one of the new markets World Rugby is seeking to break into, such as the United States, is not going to watch that game and want to see more.

But as long as it works, the Springboks will keep doing it.

When teams cannot handle the high ball, it is a legitimate attacking weapon. When they can, it becomes a counterattacking platform and the bombs essentially amount to kicking the ball away.

On Saturday, the tactic was the former.

If the All Blacks can handle those bombs better, it will become the latter — and it will force the Springboks to develop a more well-rounded game.

It is a return to the beginning of a cycle that began a generation ago.

In 2009, the Springboks beat the All Blacks three times.

Just as they do now, there were plenty of attacking threats in that team. They just did not want to use them.

Morne Steyn launched a plethora of bombs for the likes of Bryan Habana and JP Pietersen to chase.

It was a tactic All Black wingers Joe Rokocoko and Sitiveni Sivivatu did not handle.

The South Africans would rely on scraps to score, while looking to Morne and Francois Steyn to knock over kicks — even in their own half, in the case of Steyn.

That caused a rethink.

Cory Jane and Israel Dagg were brought in and barely dropped a high ball. Rokocoko improved and Mils Muliaina was his typical solid self.

They formed a back three that proved lethal on the counterattack a year later, as the All Blacks swept aside the Springboks.

Those kicks became launching pads. A year later, Richard Kahui joined Jane and Dagg to form the 2011 World Cup’s ‘‘bomb squad’’.

Crucially, it forced the Springboks to adapt. The high ball was no longer an attacking threat, so they had to develop a more well-rounded game.

By 2013, they had done that. South Africa became a team that played genuinely impressive all-round rugby and its backline became dangerous.

Would the Springboks have changed had the All Blacks not forced their hand?

Maybe. But it is hard to see it.

As long as a tactic works, a team will keep using it.

For the sake of rugby, New Zealand and Australia need to ensure it does not work.

All Blacks v Springboks
Contrasting numbers
All Blacks                  Springboks

18                Kicks                38
142            Passes                 66
7.9       Passes per kick          1.7
17     Passes by midfielders     3
97              Carries                  65
402       Metres carried          255
13             Offloads                 1

Add a Comment


Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter