Man had no help for years

A man died in the collision that caused Chris Wesley’s injuries in 2009. Photo: Supplied
A man died in the collision that caused Chris Wesley’s injuries in 2009. Photo: Supplied
Ten years after a devastating car crash, the Southern District Health Board has apologised for not attempting to diagnose a former Dunedin man’s brain injury which likely contributed to years of an inability to hold a job and outbursts of anger.

On May 28, 2009, Chris Wesley was driving on State Highway 1, near Edendale, in low visibility and hail when another vehicle crossed the centre line and collided with him.

The other driver died and Mr Wesley was treated for tooth, jaw and other facial injuries at Southland Hospital.

Chris Wesley
Chris Wesley
After this Mr Wesley, who lived in Dunedin, went back to work ‘‘agitated, tired’’ and with bouts of amnesia.

‘‘I started experiencing psychotic episodes.’’

He began acting in ways he had never done before, which he was now ‘‘embarrassed’’ about.

In 2010 he was charged with assault with intent to injure in relation to an altercation with his wife and spent a month in prison, but was discharged without conviction on mental health grounds.

However, from that point Otago Mental Health Services did not believe he had mental health issues, he said.

Notes from doctors and nurses about Mr Wesley’s case obtained under the Official Information Act support his claim, including one which said it was difficult to assess his state as he was ‘‘not doing a very good job acting like he has a mental illness’’.

These diagnoses followed him everywhere he went as the health board passed his notes on, such as when he moved to Taranaki, meaning he could not get adequate treatment, he said.

‘‘I haven’t been able to hold down jobs, lost relationships. I had months sleeping in my car surrounded by cider bottles.’’

In 2018 he began a process through the Accident Compensation Corporation (ACC) and the ‘‘penny finally dropped’’.

Physicians diagnosed his head injuries and linked them to post-traumatic stress disorder and depression.

He is now on a concussion rehabilitation plan through ACC and was ‘‘finally getting really good treatment’’.

He laid a complaint with the Health and Disability Commissioner and last month received some closure in an apology from the Southern District Health Board.

A letter from medicine and women’s and children’s health directorate acting general manager Simon Donlevy said it was ‘‘very clear’’ from his condition at the time that he had suffered a head injury and a CT scan was performed which the radiologist identified as normal.

However, the health board was ‘‘sorry’’ there did not appear to be a specific assessment of the severity of his head injury or the potential risk of post-concussion syndrome.

‘‘The lack of appreciation of the possibility that you suffered a traumatic brain injury has clearly had a detrimental effect on your treatment and we are also very sorry if the lack of this documentation influenced your treatment providers.’’

Mr Wesley said it was ‘‘very sincere’’ and was helping him to move on.

However, he did not receive the apology he sought regarding the ongoing treatment from Otago Mental Health services.

SDHB chief medical officer Nigel Millar said yesterday it was sorry to hear of Mr Wesley’s ongoing difficulties.

‘‘We acknowledge and take seriously Mr Wesley’s concerns. These have been investigated and we have the advised him of the outcomes of them,’’ Dr Millar said.

‘‘Whilst we can’t comment on individual case details, if Mr Wesley has any further concerns we would be very happy to discuss these with him directly and we will make contact with Mr Wesley to provide him with this opportunity.”

Now he is staying with friends in Auckland and was getting to a point where he wanted to leave the long saga behind him.

He also wanted to raise awareness of the effects undiagnosed head injuries could have on your life.

‘‘It’s to say to people if they feel unwell after a head injury to insist to their GPs. The downstream impacts are huge.’’


There was a pattern in both public and private mh services of treating complex conditions as character flaws or factitious.

An apology is that all he gets?, and nothing from mental health services.
The mental health services in NZ are a joke. Seems to me that if you need mental health help then don't go to the police or mental health services because they will say your lying.

Not entirely. The police will say of mh 'uncooperative bstds!' and, 'we're not really a taxi service'.

I sympathize with Mr Wesley and have struck the exact roadblocks even after seeking help, even after submissions on mental health services the service and other services remain inadequate, "the further south the worse the care..."



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter