Vatican's response to abuse labelled failure

Dr Murray Heasley speaks to media while in Rome this week, during a major gathering of bishops called by Pope Francis to discuss the sexual abuse crisis engulfing the Catholic Church. Photo: Analyn Heasley
Dr Murray Heasley speaks to media while in Rome this week, during a major gathering of bishops called by Pope Francis to discuss the sexual abuse crisis engulfing the Catholic Church. Photo: Analyn Heasley
A former Dunedin man who performed a haka to challenge the Vatican's handling of child sexual abuse says the Pope's response to the issue has been ''a catastrophic failure of empathy and respect''.

Dr Murray Heasley, now an Auckland-based spokesman for the Network of Survivors of Abuse in Faith-based Institutions and their Supporters, is a former Dunedin pupil and student.

He travelled to the Vatican as New Zealand's representative on the Ending Clergy Abuse Global (ECAG) group, which staged meetings and events timed to coincide with a gathering of bishops from around the world.

The bishops' gathering, called to discuss the sexual abuse crisis engulfing the Roman Catholic church, wrapped up earlier this week with a pledge from Pope Francis that the church would ''spare no effort'' to tackle the issue.

The outcome outraged campaigners, who criticised the Pope's failure to commit the church to ''zero tolerance'' for paedophile priests and cover-ups.

He was also accused of being defensive about the issue after describing the church's critics as ''relatives of the devil''.

Dr Heasley, contacted in Italy yesterday, told ODT Insight the outcome was a major let-down for the survivors who travelled from 21 countries to attend events coinciding with the conference.

''It displayed a tone-deafness and insensitivity to the victims of the most horrific child sex abuse that was particularly unfortunate given the reason for the summit,'' he said.

Among the survivors was Dunedin man Darryl Smith, who travelled to the Vatican hoping for an audience with Pope Francis.

He was carrying a letter of introduction from Dunedin Bishop the Most Rev Michael Dooley, who also helped pay for his trip, but Mr Smith was turned away from the gates to the Vatican by its Swiss Guard.

Mr Smith said he was also left ''downhearted'' after Cardinal John Dew, of Wellington, declined to meet him while in Rome.

Mr Smith was New Zealand's only survivor at the event, and had met two other Catholic bishops - from Ireland and Canada - while there.

But Cardinal Dew had said he was ''very busy'' and unable to do the same, despite being the official representative of the Catholic Church in New Zealand at the event, Mr Smith said.

''If two different cardinals could see me, why couldn't he see me?

''He should have made it a part of his mission to see me, because I'm the only New Zealand survivor, in survivor week, from New Zealand.''

A spokeswoman for the New Zealand Catholic Bishops Conference declined to comment on Cardinal Dew's decision this week.

Dr Heasley said the only positive to come from events in Rome was a ''clear shift'' in the narrative, towards the voices of survivors and advocates.

That included a haka performed by Dr Heasley at St Peter's Square, which drew international media attention and sought to show survivors were now ''warriors in a battle in which we will prevail''.

It also included support from the Ending Clergy Abuse Global (ECAG) group, which endorsed a resolution from Dr Heasley calling on the Vatican to instruct New Zealand's bishops to open all archives to independent scrutiny.

''New Zealand is now squarely in the global spotlight after this Rome summit,'' Dr Heasley said.


Crimes against people cannot be obscured by the fog of Religionist attribution to Supernatural causes, ie The Devil.

And the church wonders why its' flock is wandering?



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter