Comment permalink

Otago MasterChef NZ contestant Felina Kee. Photo: Instagram
Otago MasterChef NZ contestant Felina Kee. Photo: Instagram
A disgruntled MasterChef NZ contestant has launched a scathing rant on social media before this weekend's premiere, alleging the show is manufactured and the judges were "fake".

Felina Kee, an Otago teacher, took to her Facebook page Food by Felina to reveal insider secrets with her followers, accompanied by a long written post outlining allegations about the way the show is run.

Media giant Warner Bros Discovery denies all the allegations and said Kee had not raised any issues or complained about the show to the production team.

MasterChef NZ is due to screen this Sunday after a six-year hiatus, featuring season 2 winner, celebrity cook and entrepreneur Nadia Lim as lead judge. She's joined by renowned chef Vaughan Mabee and award-winning restaurateur Michael Dearth.

MasterChef NZ judges Michael P. Dearth, Nadia Lim and Vaughan Mabee ahead of Sunday's night's premiere. Photo / Supplied
MasterChef NZ judges Michael P. Dearth, Nadia Lim and Vaughan Mabee ahead of Sunday's night's premiere. Photo / Supplied

Twenty-seven contestants are vying to win one of the 16 coveted aprons and make it to the new MasterChef kitchen at Vingard near Arrowtown.

In her Facebook post, Kee said as "the show is about to air, so is their dirty laundry".

She believed the judges were "puppets" and claimed they were fed lines through an ear-piece. On one occasion, she alleges dishes hadn't been tasted by the judges yet they were filmed commenting on the meals.

She claimed that "all the contestants were aware that they had never tasted the food but were making these judgments, that were all fake and false".

And Kee added that in her opinion "it didn't matter how our food had been cooked, the judges had made a decision, most likely based on what they had been told by the director, on which contestants' food was going to go through".

A Discovery spokeswoman denied this saying, the "judges' opinions are very much their own".

Kee also claimed when she told staff she was going to leave the show because of a "toxic" environment", a senior staff member went to her room and "offered to give me inside information about the next challenge so that I would have an unfair advantage over the others".

She also claimed the TV show was highly manipulated and convoluted, and "dangerous" to contestants' mental health.

Discovery denied the show was an unsafe workplace, saying it looks after contestants "extremely well".

"Their well-being is our constant concern," a spokeswoman said.

"They are in five-star accommodation, get an allowance, have food, breaks and needs attended to, and have a dedicated person constantly on hand to keep them informed of the production process and attend to any needs or concerns they have. Catering and hydration is available on set at all times."

"Production has a fulltime health and safety officer who absolutely complies with all New Zealand WorkSafe health and safety regulations."

Some of Kee's allegations include:

• The show took contestants' watches off them and the time displayed on the famous MasterChef clock was changed frequently to fit filming.
• Contestants were given faulty equipment to work with in hopes it would create better TV.
• Contestants were chosen and eliminated based on personality, not cooking ability.
• She claimed a staff member told her "don't worry, you're already in" before judges had tasted her dish.
• The contestants were forced to cook in unsafe conditions and the experience had been "psychological manipulation".

In her post she also attempts to "get ahead of the smear campaign" by saying she has proof via medical certificates that she did not leave because of injury, which she claimed would be a likely cover-up for her sudden departure from the show.

Kee claimed she left after a recommendation by the show's counsellor that the show was detrimental to her mental state. She claims to have fled in the middle of the night.

She went on to allege that she risked facing civil court action and being sued by Discovery for speaking out.

During her live video, Kee encouraged MasterChef to "sue her for her last $10".

"I'm broke - but I'm happy."

Kee became emotional near the end of the video, saying she saw the experience as "psychological manipulation".

"It's not okay.

"It's really quite scary they are allowed to do this to me, that this is in some way justified."

Discovery's spokeswoman said Kee's comments "seriously defame the production company, the series, its broadcaster, the format owners, the Judges, talent appearing in, and crew working on the series".

The claims about the show were "false and malicious".

"At no time has Felina Kee complained to anyone from the production about the way she was treated by the production, during production or after she chose to leave," she said.

"We offer all contestants professional care in the form of follow-up sessions with the show psychologist, in line with our duty of care protocols."

She said Kee' claims were causing mental distress to the MasterChef NZ contestants and judges.

"Our biggest concern now is to support the cast and crew from MasterChef NZ who have enjoyed their time and are excited for the show to air on Sunday," she said.

In response to Kee's claim the show created an environment so toxic she was advised to leave by the show's onsite counsellor, Discovery's spokeswoman said she couldn't comment on the advice given to Kee.

"However, all contestants are police vetted and interviewed by a registered cognitive behavioural therapist psychologist before they enter the show to ensure it is appropriate for them to participate in the programme," she said.

She also denied the judges were told how to judge the food.

"All three judges are at the top of their game in the industry and would not put their reputations on the line unless it was authentic," she said.

"Like all television shows, the director does sometimes speak to them via an earpiece to direct, but the director does not tell the judges what to say about their critique of the food."

She also said MasterChef was first and foremost a cooking show rather than a popularity contest.

"Contestants are judged on their cooking ability. The progression through the series is based on cooking ability. Nothing is predetermined."

She said it was not true conditions on the MasterChef set were not safe.

Contestants have support "from the producer, health and safety officer, an onset nurse, the production manager and the story producers. Their well-being is our constant concern".

She said contestants were also given many breaks during filming.


Most viewers acknowledge Master chef and similar are manufactured towards entertainment . Those judges have the followings to be TV judges but put them in a 200-300 covers a day alacarte kitchen and see how they go? The exposure of this mess is just a shame for all involved but no surprises really.

Dualistic viewing*

The judges turn down meals, the viewers often starve.

I stopped watching these shows whether NZ or Aust as they seemed hollow long ago. I do not care one way or the other but a little 'get real' in what food is simple to cook and wholesome might do more for people who cannot afford less common ingrediants or so much time.

Does it really take an expose from a participant to illustrate the pretty obvious fact that most of these 'competitions' are comprehensively contrived, from cooking to building to decorating to 'survival' to goodness-knows how many other shows. They are designed to be first and foremost entertainment, so reality takes a back seat.

There's more entertainment watching paint dry or the grass growing.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter