The Public Health Association (PHA) has gone into damage-control over its widely-panned opposition to Ronald McDonald House, claiming its position was "misrepresented''.
The public health advocates' opposition to a Ronald McDonald House in the rebuilt Dunedin Hospital has attracted a barrage of public criticism in the South.
Yesterday, in a statement titled ``Public Health Association widely misrepresented on Ronald McDonald House Charities'', chief executive Warren Lindberg said the association supported providing accommodation for sick children and families.
However, Mr Lindberg's statement reiterated the main point in the association's original statement opposing the multinational-backed charity.
``Our criticism is of the undesirable marketing of the fast food industry arising from the naming rights held by the McDonald's brand,'' Mr Lindberg said.
``Funds to maintain the services provided to families come from community fundraising efforts and Ministry of Health subsidies as well as from the fast food industry.
``Yet by holding the naming rights, there is a powerful perception that the service is dependent on the generosity of McDonald's.
``People are unaware of the funding sources and of the power of branding.
Mr Lindberg called on McDonald's to ``give up the naming rights'' while continuing to provide financial support.
Southern District Health Board's public health arm Public Health South has said Ronald McDonald's presence in the health sector ``contradicts basic public health principles''.
While the DHB's overall position is neutral, it has been criticised due to the view of its public health arm.
An online petition calling on the board to support a Ronald McDonald facility had more than 9500 signatures yesterday.
Petition organiser Jacqui Hellyer, of Dunedin, said she was surprised by the number of signatures it attracted in three days.
Mrs Hellyer stayed at Ronald McDonald houses in Christchurch and Auckland with her daughter. ``If you're away from home needing medical care with your child they're essential.''
Mrs Hellyer plans to present the petition to health board commissioner Kathy Grant later this month.
National Waitaki MP Jacqui Dean weighed in to criticise the public health advocates.
``I think the Otago-Southland Public Health Association has failed to understand the caring principles and core values around the Ronald McDonald philosophy and I do not think they have the right to deny families the opportunity to access these facilities.''
Mrs Dean said the Ronald McDonald Family Room in Southland Hospital provided ``amazing support''.
Last month, Counties Manukau DHB dropped plans for a Ronald McDonald House in Middlemore Hospital after taking advice from public health staff.
There is no formal proposal as yet, but the charity has expressed interest in establishing one in the new Dunedin Hospital.
Related Stories
Comments
Of course the Waitaki MP Jaqui DEAN would weigh in. This discussion is not about providing a place for families to stay when they are having hospital treatment. Would we not allow an alcohol or tobacco company naming rights? No, that was dropped years ago. Better that the Cancer Society or other charity service provide it.
Gosh, yes, let some "other charity" provide it. We'll just arrange another street appeal on top of the one we already run to beg for money for essential medical equipment for kids with a life threatening, untreatable condition. Should be a doddle to fit it in between hospital visits, travel to other centres for specialist assessments, treatments, physio... oh yeah, and trying to earn a living with a chronically ill child.
Rather than listen to a group of public health zealots who rarely if ever have much to do with actual patients and their families it would be better for the DHB to listen to the GPs, health professionals and families who are far more aware of the issues surrounding Ronald McDonald House.
Time for the PHA to crawl back into their ivory towers and let real people get on with their lives. Ironically, the last (and one of the very few ) time I went to McDonalds was when taken by a PHA member!
The Otago-Southland Public Health Association continue to prove themselves as being a bunch of back room academics pushing a political / social agenda totally divorced from everyday life.
These same people are steadily moving on from the anti smoking campaign and are opposing sugar, fast food and alcohol. All in the name of what they think is good for us.
I wonder how they would get on if, like Ronald McDonald house, they had to raise the funds to pay for their organisation rather than suck on the government teat?