'We've acted as if we're bullet proof': Expert blasts lack of border testing

Sir David Skegg
Sir David Skegg
The lack of testing of staff at the border is extraordinary, a prominent Otago University epidemiologist says.

Health officials are frantically trying to trace the origin of the Covid-19 cluster in Auckland, which could have come from the border.

Otago University Professor Sir David Skegg told Morning Report reports showed more than 60% of staff working at the border had never been tested.

"I was really shocked to hear the director general of health say a week or two ago that they were aiming to test people [border workers] every two or three weeks, every two or three weeks frankly would be quite inadequate.

"But it now turns out that nothing like that was being achieved and I see the reports that more than 60 per cent of people working at the border have never been tested."

Weekly testing for frontline staff working at the border should have been compulsory as stringent border protection is vital for New Zealand's elimination strategy, Skegg said.

He said he has heard that people have declined tests and some of the contracting companies declined to implement testing.

"For many years there have been industries where if you work in a particular industry you agree to have blood tests or whatever to make sure you are not getting exposed to particular risks and I think it is absolutely vital for our elimination status to have the most stringent protections at the border."

He said the virus has clearly been spreading for some time, and New Zealand will be extremely lucky if it has not spread outside Auckland.

Skegg said New Zealand has beaten Covid before and we can do it again but it is important to learn from the mistakes.

"Not just the breach at the border, but also the fact that there have been such delays in detecting this because of a lack of testing."

It would be interesting to know if any of the cases of community transmission had sought a Covid test but had been declined by a doctor, he said.

Skegg said we have let ourselves down with complacency and "we've acted as if we're bullet proof".

"Complacency is one of our national characteristics, sadly."

He said the alert level change will depend on where the new cases are revealed today.

"I'd be very surprised if the current restrictions aren't at least continued, if not increased."

He said security needs to be ramped up at the border to detect any Covid cases as soon as possible.

New Zealand also needs to ensure that sufficient masks are available and to ramp up contact tracing, he said.

Skegg said everyone should be downloading the contact tracing app, which is a long way from perfect but the best New Zealand has.

It is vital for the whole country to use the same QR code which fits with the Government's app and shops should get rid of any that are non-compliant, Skegg said.

He said people should be wearing masks if they are going to be in indoor locations where they are going to be close to other people because it has been known for some time that masks are effective is hampering Covid's spread.

He said New Zealand has enjoyed a period of normality which is exceptional around the world and hopefully the country will learn from this mistake and get over it very quickly.


Skegg came across as cranky and aristocratic on RNZ this morning. Clearly the MoH could and should have pushed harder with this, but expressing outrage isn't likely to help in an already tense situation and isn't what we should expect of such a senior public health figure. He could learn something about communication from one of the excellent younger epidemiologists who have been informing the public through the pandemic, ironically he probably taught half of them at some point.

He didn't come across as at all cranky or aristocratic (where did that come from?) to me - just level headed and sensible.

The thing is you could get tested and still have someone infect you while your waiting for results. All the "experts" act like they know what they are talking about but I don't think they do. They all are quick to complain and point out government short falls weeks after they occur. Face it, nobody really has a solution. We are stumbling through this thing together hoping for the best.



Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter