Prominent Otago man who worked with youth cleared of sexual assault

The trial is being heard at the Timaru District Court. Photo: ODT files
The trial was heard at the Timaru District Court. Photo: ODT files
A prominent Otago man hugged his supporters after being cleared of sexual assault charges this afternoon.

A jury found the man, who still has interim name suppression, not guilty of sexual violation by unlawful sexual connection, doing an indecent act on a young person and indecent assault.

The Crown case was that the defendant had gained the trust of the teenage boy through his role working with youth and sexually offended against him between 2014 and 2019.

Prosecutor Andrew McRae said the man had groomed the complainant and abused his position of trust.

“The Crown say that [the defendant] was like a grandfather to the complainant, he was obviously a mentor to him, he encouraged him to be his best and he gained the trust of his parents as well,” Mr McRae.

“Things took a sinister turn.”

The complainant told the jury: "I feel like I trusted him and other people trusted him and he was well known,” the complainent said.

He said the complainant had been an honest and believable witness.

But the jury rejected that narrative, instead believing the defence that the complainant was “a bit of a story-teller”.

The defendant had “emphatically” denied the allegations and after he was arrested in 2023, told police he would “never ever ever” sexually abuse the boy.

"That would be putting aside everything I’ve stood for all my life, it just didn’t happen,” the defendant told Detective Mark Durant.

In closing to the jury, counsel Philip Hall KC said his client’s police interview had “the ring of honesty” to it.

“You could almost feel the outrage and disgust in the way he responded to the allegations… he appeared to be absolutely genuine,” Mr Hall said.

When Det Durant asked the defendant about the allegation he sexually violated the teenager, he replied "not true, absolutely not true".

"In his dreams," the defendant said.

"He’s a likeable enough young man, [but] he exaggerates, he had bits of illusion, he can be a bit of a story-teller," the defendant said.

The defendant said he was "appalled" by the allegations.

"I think he looked up to me.

"I don’t know why he’s doing this."

After the verdicts this afternoon, the defendant was discharged and hugged his supporters in the back of the court room.

A hearing for final name suppression was set down for October 3.

felicity.dear@odt.co.nz