Deportation order stands for Balclutha woman

Immigration New Zealand is refusing to budge on its order to deport a Balclutha woman to Fiji.

Firoza Begum
Firoza Begum

Firoza Begum (57) moved to the South Otago town after her husband, Mohammed Kalim (63), took upwork in 2007 as a halal butcher at the Finegand processing plant.

Mrs Begum worked at New World Balclutha until 2016, when she had a severe stroke that left her in a wheelchair.

Despite the stroke, Mr Kalim said the couple's working visas continued to be renewed until 2018.

Only Mr Kalim's visa was approved this year.

He thought INZ mislaid his wife's annual working visa application and by the time it emerged in March this year, she had become an unintentional overstayer, which led to an order to deport her.

INZ operations support manager Michael Carley said correspondence with Mrs Begum and her family indicated they intended to return to Fiji in September, and INZ did not intend to undertake ''any compliance action'' at this time.

However, he confirmed Mrs Begum was unlawfully in New Zealand and under an obligation to leave the country.

He said her work visa application, made in 2018, was declined on health grounds earlier this year.

''It was found she did not have an acceptable standard of health and was likely to impose significant costs on New Zealand's health system.

''After she was provided with the opportunity to comment and provide further information, consideration of her case found she didn't meet the criteria to be granted a medical waiver, nor were there sufficient reasons to grant her an exception.''

Mohammed Kalim.
Mohammed Kalim.

Mr Carley said the 2018 visa application was delayed because it was incorrectly filed with her husband's application.

''INZ apologised for the oversight and ensured the application was processed as promptly as possible.

''While this application was being processed, Mrs Begum was automatically granted a six-month interim visa to maintain her lawful status in New Zealand while her work visa application was being considered.

''During this period, the applicant's interim visa expired on January 21, 2019, which led to the applicant becoming unlawful.''

When asked what recourse she had to resolve the issue and allow her to stay in Balclutha, Mr Carley said those unlawfully in New Zealand had no legal right to apply for another visa, and INZ was not obliged to consider any request for a further visa.

Mr Kalim said he was angry and disappointed.

He said they could have left the country before the visas ran out, to avoid becoming an overstayer, but they did not because they believed Mrs Begum's application would be approved.

Their only hope now was there would not be a ''black mark'' against Mrs Begum's name, which would prevent her from visiting family in New Zealand when her health improved.

The couple would return to Fiji on Saturday, and hoped family members there would accommodate them in the interim.


Having worked overseas with large companies such as Mr Kalim is presently doing ,I would say that we (NZ) are somewhat behind the times in expat employment benefits offered by many other countries. If a work permit supports a person it should support the spouse and children, the company/corporation that supported that work visa should then have to provide all insurance and protection for such matters. All this started in 2007 until now , where has their support and advise been placed..? Not in the right direction by all concerned it would seem.






Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter