Tackle completely unnecessary: law professor

Mark Henaghan.
Mark Henaghan.
The tackle which felled a streaker at Forsyth Barr Stadium on Saturday night was ''totally unnecessary'', legal expert Prof Mark Henaghan says.

The University of Otago dean of law told the Otago Daily Times yesterday he believed there was ''no need'' for security guard and New Zealand under-20 rugby team triallist Brad Hemopo to tackle 28-year-old streaker Adam Holtslag, of Christchurch.

''He hit him from behind which is dangerous,'' he said.

''That's when you can get hurt.''

''You can use reasonable force to defend yourself or to defend others but in this case I think it was totally unnecessary.''

Mr Hemopo's tackle on Mr Holtslag, during the 62nd minute of the All Blacks-England test match on Saturday, has since hit headlines internationally and divided public opinion.

Prof Henaghan said the suggestion a security guard could behave with more force than a non-uniformed person was wrong and the fact the incident occurred on a rugby field did not change the situation.

''It's not exempt just because you're on a rugby paddock.''

He did not believe the players were at risk and Mr Holtslag appeared to have his hands up and was walking from the field.

Mr Holtslag's intoxication and nudity were also irrelevant, he said.

''The law protects you whether you are behaving like an idiot or not,'' he said.

The idea Mr Holtslag deserved on-field punishment for streaking was also wrong as ''that's the court's job''.

Anyone could lay a complaint to police but they had ''total discretion'' as to whether to prosecute, he said.

Dunedin Venues Management Ltd chief executive Terry Davies said he was comfortable with the force used to remove Mr Holtslag from the field.

''I think the tackle was appropriate,'' he said.

''If he [Mr Holtslag] was in motion we wouldn't have even been having this discussion.''

Mr Davies was confident Mr Hemopo was licensed and accredited for the job and had acted according to his ''brief''.

''The reality is we have a responsibility to the players ... safety is of paramount importance.''

New Zealand Rugby chief executive Steve Tew said Mr Holtslag put himself and the players ''at risk by his foolish actions''.

''We expect test match venues to take quick and decisive action when there is anything that threatens the safe operation of a match.''

When contacted yesterday, Mr Hemopo again said he was unable to speak about Saturday's incident.

Attempts to contact the security contractor yesterday were unsuccessful.

Mr Davies said DVML would review the ''deployment of staff'' to attempt to prevent streakers getting on the pitch.


Add a Comment

Local journalism matters - now more than ever

As the Covid-19 pandemic brings the world into uncharted waters, Otago Daily Times reporters and photographers continue to bring you the stories that matter. For more than 158 years our journalists have provided readers with local news you can trust. This is more important now than ever.

As advertising drops off during the pandemic, support from our readers is crucial. You can help us continue to bring you news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter