'Blatantly racist' message left on Pasifika academic's phone

An Auckland academic who had just spoken at a public event about her successful career as a Pasifika woman was shocked to discover a hate-filled "racist rant" left on her voicemail.

Dr Jemaima Tiatia-Seath, co-head of Te Wānanga o Waipapa - the School of Māori Studies and Pacific Studies - at the University of Auckland, shared seven minutes of listener feedback online following a Sunday event aired on Radio New Zealand.

The diatribe has been denounced by Race Relations Commissioner Meng Foon, who says while such incidents were sadly common, no one should be reduced to receiving racist taunts.

Tiatia-Seath's speech touched on the pay gap between Māori and Pasifika academics and the evidence showing Pasifika women academics earn about $7000 less than their male counterparts.

Dr Jemaima Tiatia-Seath, co-head of the School of Māori Studies and Pacific Studies at the...
Dr Jemaima Tiatia-Seath, co-head of the School of Māori Studies and Pacific Studies at the University of Auckland. Photo: NZ Herald
The lecturer's talk was well-received by attendees, but when she checked her voicemail later, she was left in disbelief by a lengthy message.

Tiatia-Seath said the woman on the line made comments that were "blatantly racist and filled with hate", including telling her to go back to the islands.

"Over here in New Zealand, the colonists and the settlers - they brought all of their knowledge here and they built here," the caller said.

"They taught the Māoris (sic) about Jesus Christ ...They taught the Māori chiefs to stop invading each other's tribes."

She asks Tiatia-Seath if she is trying to "push your culture", before telling her that Polynesians arrived in New Zealand about 60 years ago - compared to her ancestors, who landed here 180 years ago.

"The way you talked last night - you behaved as if you owned New Zealand. You don't. You're all a late arrival," the caller said, her tone becoming more high-pitched as she continues.

Racism: 'It was an opportunity to call it out'

Tiatia-Seath said she shared the message on social media in a bid to show the ugliness of racism.

"What was said is basically a verbalised sample of how some New Zealanders think," she told the New Zealand Herald.

"The point of sharing that was to expose the ugliness. You take the bad with the good - you don't necessarily have to take the ugly."

Born in Tokoroa and raised in West Auckland, Tiatia-Seath said she rolled her eyes at the message, but also felt hurt.

"There was a pain - and not for me. It was for the future and for all that Pacific [people] do. The pain was for those who came before me - for [people] who were killed for speaking out like this."

A legacy left behind

Tiatia-Seath, whose family hails from Samoa, paid tribute to her grandparents and other migrants who came to New Zealand looking for new hope.

"This land offers prosperity and success just to be ... and that kind of rant is an attack on all that we are."

However, the woman's rant had also been "one hundred per cent" motivational.

"Last week we saw graduation and we saw these students carrying their names, their ancestors and their beliefs. What that says to me is that you can't hold us down.

"And that's the legacy we're going to leave behind."

Foon said the woman's comments were "silly behaviour" and "immature".

Pasifika, Māori and Asian academics were often subjected to these experiences, he said.

"It's microaggressions. It happens in little bits and pieces, but they do end up, cumulatively, very hurtful and demoralising. Sometimes people feel they are strong ... but it does wear people down.

"We should all be safe in our environments, regardless of our heritage, ethnicity, religion, gender."

Foon sent his aroha to Tiatia-Seath, her family and peers.

The incident follows comments from National's education spokesman Paul Goldsmith last weekend that colonisation "on balance" had been a good thing for Māori.

Goldsmith had been taking aim at the proposed New Zealand history curriculum which has a focus on teaching colonisation and its impacts, particularly on Māori, and topics such as white privilege.

Yesterday Justice Minister Kris Faafoi told Parliament's justice select committee that proposed changes to hate speech laws wouldn't criminalise opinions or the "stupid" things people say unless they stir up hatred towards a particular group.

Faafoi said public consultation on the proposals would take place "very soon".



This doesn't surprise me one little bit. Taika Waititi was correct when he said that NZ is a racist country. I know a number of ordinary NZer's who share the views of this gutless anonymous caller and most of them are bright enough to know that their views are not acceptable and only open their mouths to express them when they are among like minded individuals.
It's an interesting game i play to amuse myself and identify who amongst my associates is racist: I do this by reacting supportively to their tentative semi racist comments and then let them open up and prove their true racist persona before shutting them down. They know they're racist but they cover it up quickly when confronted, not because they think it is wrong but because they know they will be publicly shamed.
I have no doubt that a large number of pakeha NZers, especially those born before the 1980's, hold inherently racist views.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter