Call for companies to repay wage subsidies

Christchurch philanthropists Grant and Marilyn Nelson. Photo: Supplied
Christchurch philanthropists Grant and Marilyn Nelson. Photo: Supplied
A former Christchurch businessman turned philanthropist estimates $5 billion has been paid out in wage subsidies to companies that do not need it.

Grant Nelson and his wife Marilyn run the Gama Foundation, which hands out the money they made after selling their business.

It has donated more than $50 million over the years and receives no donations. Over the years the foundation has given millions of dollars to conservation, research, disability, and educational causes, including $50,000 recently to Professor Michael Baker for his work on Covid-19.

Mr Nelson says companies that made more profit last year than they did in 2019 should repay their wage subsidies immediately.

He told RNZ Checkpoint reporter Nita Blake-Persen the government needs to take a more proactive approach in encouraging companies to do that.

"There have been some random audits but not nearly enough, because there were 760,000 recipients of the wage subsidy. So any audits they do are reaching very few of those who received the wage subsidy.

"That is why I think everyone who received the wage subsidy should be contacted. Then if they can prove they were entitled to it then they can retain it. Otherwise they should be repaying it.

"I could see it was open to abuse and that has been the problem. It has been abused by those who didn't really need it ... most businesses could have got through the (lockdown) without the wage subsidy.

"So, yes, it did help at the time, but I think now that we can see the big picture of what has happened last year, then businesses who didn't really need the wage subsidy should be repaying it."

Mr Nelson estimated $5 billion has been paid out in wage subsidies to companies that do not necessarily need it.  And he is calling on businesses that have made profits over the past year to "act more ethically" and "repay the subsidy".

"Then that money could be used for those who are in greater need."


Mr and Mrs Nelson are dead right. The companies who have found that they didn't need the wage subsidy should refund it back to the public who gave it to them.
A number of leading retailers and manufacturers are showing the way and have refunded all or part of the subsidy.
Those who are keeping it and there have been some who went public stating their intention to keep the "windfall", are dispicable.
I guarantee you, these will the same people who will cheat on their taxes, who will bemoan an increase in the minimum wage, who will add 25% to their already exorbitant prices on statutory holidays, who will condemn beneficiaries as parasites and a drain on the economy.
If I learn of any of these scum I shall be naming and shaming within my community and I would expect the news media to do the same.

In Old World terms, this couple are aristocrats.
The shabby mercantile are nouveau riche.

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter