Trump bid to overturn election stumbles as judge tosses Pennsylvania lawsuit

President Trump's hopes of overturning the election result in Pennsylvania have taken another...
President Trump's hopes of overturning the election result in Pennsylvania have taken another blow. Photo: Getty Images
President Donald Trump's desperate bid to overturn the US election was dealt a new setback on Saturday when a federal judge threw out his campaign's attempt to invalidate millions of votes in Pennsylvania.

US District Court Judge Matthew Brann ruled that the Trump campaign's efforts to stop Pennsylvania officials from certifying Democrat Joe Biden as the winner in the state was "unsupported by evidence."

"This Court has been presented with strained legal arguments without merit and speculative accusations," Brann wrote.

"In the United States of America, this cannot justify the disenfranchisement of a single voter, let alone all the voters of its sixth most populated state," he wrote.

The lawsuit sought to stop officials from certifying Biden's victory in the state, arguing that some counties wrongly allowed voters to fix errors on their mail ballots.

Republican Senator Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania said Trump had "exhausted all plausible legal options" to challenge the result in Pennsylvania. He called on Trump to concede the election and congratulated Biden on his victory.

Few other Republicans in Congress have called on Trump to concede.

Trump's lawyers said they would appeal the ruling, with the hopes of quickly reaching the US Supreme Court.

"We are disappointed we did not at least get the opportunity to present our evidence at a hearing. Unfortunately the censorship continues," Rudy Giuliani and Jenna Ellis said in a statement.

For Trump to have any hope of overturning the election, he needs to reverse the outcome in Pennsylvania, which is scheduled to be certified by state officials on Monday.

Democrats said Saturday's scathing verdict was further proof that Trump's accusations of fraud are baseless.

"Our country will not tolerate Trump's attempt to reverse the results of an election that he decisively lost," Biden spokesman Michael Gwin said in a statement.

Giuliani, who made his first courtroom appearance in 30 years for a hearing in the case on Tuesday, has floated a variety of conspiracy theories as the Trump team alleged that the election was marred by widespread voter fraud.

Donald Trump's lawyer Rudy Giuliani. Photo: Getty Images
Donald Trump's lawyer Rudy Giuliani. Photo: Getty Images
Trump did not directly address the ruling as he re-aired familiar grievances on Twitter. "Fake ballots, dead people voting, no Republican Poll Watchers allowed, & more!" he wrote.

Election officials across the country say there was no widespread fraud, and Trump's own administration has called the election "the most secure in American history."

Trump's campaign and its allies have filed dozens of lawsuits across the country challenging the results.

They have had little success so far, and time is running out to build a case as some states have started formalizing results. In Pennsylvania, counties are due to file official results on Monday to the secretary of state, who will then certify the tallies. Biden leads Trump by more than 81,000 votes in the state.

Benjamin Geffen of the Public Interest Law Center, who was involved in the case, said Saturday's ruling showed Trump will not be able to overturn Biden's Pennsylvania victory in court.

"As far as litigation goes I believe this is the end of the line for them," he said.


Trump is seeking to invalidate or change the election results through recounts and direct pressure on lawmakers in several states. He would need to prevail in at least three states to prevent Biden from being sworn in as president on Jan. 20 -- an unprecedented action.

In Michigan, Republicans wrote to state authorities on Saturday asking them to wait 14 days to certify Biden's victory to allow for an audit of ballots in Wayne County, which includes the majority-Black city of Detroit. The letter cited allegations of "irregularities" that have not been substantiated. Biden won 154,000 more votes than Trump in Michigan.

That effort faces long odds. A spokesperson for Michigan's top election authority said state law does not allow for audits before the vote is certified, which is due to take place on Monday. Allegations of widespread fraud have been found to be baseless, the spokesperson said.

Two leading Republican Michigan lawmakers who came to Washington at Trump's behest said after meeting him on Friday that they had no information that would change the outcome of the election in the state.

In Wisconsin, an official said poorly trained observers for the Trump campaign were slowing a partial recount by challenging every ballot and raising other objections.

"Observers are disruptive. They are asking question after question, telling the tabulators to stop, stop what they're doing and that is out of line, that's not acceptable," Milwaukee County Clerk George Christianson told reporters.

A manual recount and audit in Georgia confirmed Biden on Friday as the winner in the southern state, the first Democratic presidential candidate to win Georgia in nearly three decades.

The Trump campaign has two business days to request a recount in Georgia. Trump's legal team has also said it plans a lawsuit in the state, but has not provided specifics.

Trump's accusations have continued to inflame his hard-core Republican base.

Hundreds of supporters gathered at the statehouse in Atlanta on Saturday, with video posted online showing speakers denouncing the media for calling Biden the election winner, as well as state Republican leaders for certifying the results.

Police in riot gear were deployed to separate them from counterprotesters who gathered nearby.

Critics say Trump's refusal to concede have serious implications for national security and the fight against the coronavirus, which has killed nearly 255,000 Americans.

Biden, who has denounced Trump's attempt to reverse the election results as "totally irresponsible", spent Saturday meeting with transition advisers and attending church.

Trump took part in a virtual summit of the 20 biggest world economies and then went to play golf at his club in Sterling, Virginia.


View all

To be expected....The judge was an Obama appointment. Trump will get a fair deal in his appeal or the US Supreme Court.

Strange that we don't hear the democrats demanding an investigation into this election, considering they were keen to examined every single aspect of the 2016 election?!...Stranger still considering they kept telling America they were the more honorable party and they were guardians of the US constitution. I wonder why they don't welcome and insist on confirming Joe Biden's supposed win?
Aren't they supposed to be 'better than Trump'???

Not really any supposition about it. The chief orange has proved he is not only a loser but a bad loser. What is the score so far? 1 minor victory and 32 cases thrown out or withdrawn or thereabouts. His only evidence so far has been his own lies, fortunately the judiciary can see this quite easily.

Too Funny! David, Trump is renting space in your head! Whats happens on 20 Jan 21 when Trump starts his 2nd Term? More Russian collusion? Too funny!!!

Quite simple. It isn't going to happen, well not legally at least. Unfortunately your reply doesn't really make sense when you think about it. If Trump was renting space in my head I would be believing his lies, which clearly I am not. Are you?

Except that will not happen

Let the games begin. Pat, David and GrIZZ, this lawsuit is now going to the supreme court which is where Trump wants it and was always the goal. Trump will win this 5 to 4 and some of the votes kicked out. Remember, denying Biden enough votes is the goal. Trump can't get 270 EV. The plan is to force the election into the house and they get to vote. Trump wins the vote. Yes, yes, I will save you the trouble in responding, "lock him up...lock him rubbish...tRump supporters man bad"! I think that covers it? The master plan is unfolding...second term right on track.

You have been clearly taken in by the Trump Guliani fake news show. Even the Republican judges have been ruling against the pathetic law suits. Anyone wishing for a second term of Trump really needs to be certified.

If it wasn't so disgusting and dangerous this would be funny. Trump has been the most appalling world leader that the world has witnessed for a long time, Pol Pot and Idi Amin were probably the last two at Trump's level. His lies about covid have killed over quarter of a million Americans, and his Pro Russia policies have weakened the Western Alliances and empowered our enemies.
Now his dishonesty and cowardice is so obvious one can only marvel at the sheer bloody minded ignorance of those people who still support him. The Republican Party has shown itself to be full of complicite, corrupt, cowardly sycophants who put their personal greed above the good of their country and it's citizens. Trump and its supporters are traitors, not just to the USA and the Western Alliances, but to humanity as well.

But GrIZZ, your winning! Why so glum? I'm looking forward to the day they march him out with the crowds screaming "Lock Him Up"!

I'm not glum, but I am concerned. tRump can still do a lot of damage so as to please his master Vladimir, and to spite everyone who didn't bow to his "I am the Fuhrer" act.
I am delighted in fact, but I will leave the celebrations until after the inauguration, when we see just how big a mess these traitors have left us.
And by the way, it's "you're winning", not "your winning".

I know David and GrIZZ are “experts” on Trump and the US elections. But I am curious when preeminent constitutional law expert Professor Alan Dershowitz voices a different opinion than our Dunedin experts. Dershowitz says Trump will be president if the election goes to court ( I know its hard to argue the facts our basement buddies present: “The chief orange has proved he is not only a loser but a bad loser”, “Pol Pot and Idi Amin were probably the last two at Trump's level”, or “Trump and its supporters are traitors”. But professor Dershowitz does a commendable job pointing out Trump is the favorite in the courts because he appointed so many of the judges at all three levels of the judicial system. I think Professor Dershowitz’s opinion holds a wee bit more “gravitas” than the basement boys. Sorry gents, very entertaining but not much credence or relevance.

View all


Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter