My nephew has just finished his secondary schooling experience. He is a classic product of NCEA. It has been a puzzling experience for his elderly parents, who forked out a considerable amount for his private-school education. My nephew and I have had to reassure them on numerous occasions that his laid-back approach to achievement under NCEA is generally the norm. His reassurances have usually been less convincing than mine.
My nephew is smart, probably the result of a genetic throwback or damage at birth. He has taken subjects including physics and maths to level 3. For those of us in the teaching game, these subjects tend to be the preserve of the more academically able students. Not that there is a hierarchy of subjects under NCEA. That would suggest an element of academic bigotry. A dubious belief that some knowledge is more difficult to master than others. Under NCEA, knowledge is knowledge is knowledge. Learning to make a decent coffee can generate credits the same as mastering the dark art of quantum physics or differential equations.
My nephew has been relatively laid-back in his approach to learning under NCEA. His parents struggled to understand how he could achieve success while lying on the couch watching Sky Sport and facilitating his ample social life. Apparently they just don’t get it because they were such social dweebs when they were young. He had to constantly reassure them school was not like in their day, a century ago.
There are no real sharp edges these days. The high-stakes pass-fail regime of school certificate is a medieval anachronism, a highly stressful rite of passage that is now a distant memory of the aged and infirm, like his mum and dad. Only real losers fail these days. Assessment is way different now. Way more user-friendly and child-oriented to ensure maximum comfort and results for least effort. Mum and Dad just needed to stop stressing out. Just chill out. Relax. Take a chill pill.
My nephew even missed a few deadlines for internals during his schooling. This completely stressed his mum. But she gets stressed if Easter is late. No worries. It’s cool, teachers usually offer re-submits. They also offer re-sits for pupils who don’t succeed first time around. The onus is on them to ensure they get decent pass rates. It is very important that teachers achieve well under NCEA. Otherwise, school administrators get antsy and nervous. School pass rates are reported in the media. They are a window to the world. Bad NCEA pass rates suggest poor teaching.
So in the past few years, with more and more assessment being done in schools by teachers, pass rates have rocketed. Maori and Pacific island achievement has also increased dramatically. Schools that were previously performing poorly have seen a dramatic increase in NCEA pass rates. Everyone is happier and more laid-back about academic success. It’s just so much easier than before. Teachers can point to 100% pass rates in internal assessments in their subjects. Students can point to the huge numbers of NCEA credits they have accumulated, often with minimal effort and stress. What a success story. It’s strange other countries haven’t seen fit to copy it.
My nephew decided not to sit a few of his external NCEA exams. This made his parents eyes bulge with disbelief. Their faces contorted, turning an unhealthy purple, in repressed rage. He reassured them he didn’t need the credits. He had enough already. It was all cool. He had done enough. They looked at me for reassurance. I just slowly nodded, a little sadly and wistfully.
I am very fond of my nephew. He is a smart guy. He has learnt the main lesson that is taught by NCEA. It is called satisificing. Put in the minimum effort in order to achieve the required result. This is the lesson NCEA emphasises to our kids. It is not that hard to understand why NZ educational achievement is slipping, under most international measures.
- Peter Lyons teaches economics at Saint Peter’s College in Epsom. He is unlikely to ever be employed by NZQA.
