Mountain bikers criticised over cattle deaths

Beef cattle negotiate the Dingle Burn Bluff. PHOTO: SUPPLIED
Beef cattle negotiate the Dingle Burn Bluff. PHOTO: SUPPLIED
Mountain bikers have been blasted as "brainless idiots" for causing the deaths of three pregnant cows after ignoring signs and spooking them on a remote Lake Hawea station.

The accident happened last week on a notorious stretch of Dingle Burn Station Rd while station farmers Nick Mead and Tim Lambeth were mustering a herd of 60 pregnant cows.

Nine cows plummeted off the remote Dingle Burn Bluff.

Six swam to safety, helped by people in boats.

Two of the survivors swam for several kilometres before they could be rescued.

Model A Fords negotiate the Dingle Burn Station Rd. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN
Model A Fords negotiate the Dingle Burn Station Rd. PHOTO: GERARD O'BRIEN
Ms Mead and Mr Lambeth criticised the mountain biking party — who they believed were from Whangarei — for bad rural etiquette by ignoring road closure and stock movement signs.

She said the riders had ignored signs placed before the muster near a Department of Conservation car park, which warned "Road closed! Stock coming out".

Her family had lost faith in the public and would resort to having a person manage the road every time they moved stock in future.

‘That’s the price we have to pay for brainless idiots," Ms Mead said.

Upper Clutha Tracks Trust chairman John Hare, of Wanaka, said the Meads’ distress was understandable.

"I am terribly sorry this has happened. There’s no accounting for what some idiots will do," he said.

Mountain Bike New Zealand president Chris Arbuckle, of Wanaka, said the incident highlighted the riders’ lack of awareness about the environment and their own safety.

"I agree entirely with the land owner.

"The mountain bikers should have turned back.

"It’s about personal responsibility. And common sense," he said.

Ms Mead said the mountain bikers also spooked themselves.

"They saw the mob and got off their bikes and climbed up the bluff to get out of the way."

When the mountain bikers were confronted, they said they thought the road was only closed for vehicles, she said.

Ms Mead said her family now regrets agreeing to public biking and walking access along the road during tenure review.

The access agreement means motorists cannot use that part of road without permission and motorists were also disregarding "no vehicle access" signs, she said.

"... we wish we had never done it. We’ve been so tolerant, but people using rural areas like this need to get themselves properly educated in rural etiquette," Ms Mead said.

Mr Lambeth confirmed recreational access could not be legally revoked.

The criticism did not include the annual Contact Epic Round Lake Hawea mountain bike race.

Mr Hare said the trust’s attitude was that the public must get consent from property owners, treat access as a privilege and accept farming operations could temporarily prevent access.

Mr Arbuckle said all mountain bikers should be familiar with the national body’s code for respect for others, the rules and tracks.


View all

These bikers should be named and shamed and made to pay for the cows lost.

Definitely. But everyone seems to engaged in general frothing that the most obvious question - are these specific people going to be held accountable in this specific case - didn't even feature as a side note. Because if they did, that would go a long way towards addressing the bigger problems.

What part of ROAD CLOSED do these idiots not understand.

If it says its closed its closed to EVERYONE even pedestrians

If it was a flooded road would they have just kept on their merry way and hopefully drowned.

Seems some of these cyclists think the rules dont apply to them and now the landowner is several thousand out of pocket because of their selfishness and stupidity.

It is after all a private road and access is granted as a privilege not a right.
Hope they have the decency to offer something but I seriously doubt it will happen

This is mind-boggling level of stupidity.

Agree with these people being held responsable , and its also a health and safety issue , so the farmers can legally close the road

In future a sign 'DANGER!, bulls on road' might get through ... I doubt these people could tell the difference as they clearly have no stock sense.

View all

Our journalists are your neighbours

We are the South's eyes and ears in crucial council meetings, at court hearings, on the sidelines of sporting events and on the frontline of breaking news.

As our region faces uncharted waters in the wake of a global pandemic, Otago Daily Times continues to bring you local stories that matter.

We employ local journalists and photographers to tell your stories, as other outlets cut local coverage in favour of stories told out of Auckland, Wellington and Christchurch.

You can help us continue to bring you local news you can trust by becoming a supporter.

Become a Supporter